4 ms·
Currently reading Dune (I'm at 50%): I work a lot with Bayensian models and I keep seeing the way Paul Atreides can "feel" the future as a perfect implementatio
by teekert 11y ago
Currently reading Dune (I'm at 50%): I work a lot with Bayensian models and I keep seeing the way Paul Atreides can "feel" the future as a perfect implementation of Bayesian thinking. He weights every minute detail in a intuitive way and computes most likely outcomes. Also, the religious parts are very nicely worked out as planted by Bene Gesserit with a very detailed, worked-out plan. I love it. Having such consistent, logic based aspects to fiction makes it feel much more like you can be the hero yourself. It teaches you something real from a story that is fake. I love books that change me rather than just entertain me. It's true philosofy.
Some of my favorites and their lessons:
Enders game -> Understanding an "enemy" makes you see their beauty, makes you not want to be enemies (dehumanizing the enemy is extremely important in warfare and in propaganda; we boycot evil Putin, we don't think of honest Russian people who "love their children too", trying to make the best out of life.).
Atlas Shrugged -> The importance of not ignoring your own wishes in a group context, the morality of rational self-interest.
Brave New World -> You can either spend time creating or you can spend it consuming.
1984 -> All the metaphors it provides just makes any discussion regarding government over-reach so much more efficient.
Little Brother -> Why privacy is more important than security: Your rulers can be wrong with catastrophic consequences.
- cousin_it 11y agoI think when a story is well told, it's easy to overlook how implausible it actually is. Paul Atreides as a rationalist hero? He's the outcome of a breeding program for people who can see the future and the rightful heir to a whole planet and a prophesied messiah of a huge religion and a supersoldier with insane fighting skills. All of that is set up before the events of the novel even begin. And then he, um, takes psychedelic drugs and magically learns what's going on in outer space. And marries a princess. The real question is what you'd do in a universe where someone else has all these gifts, but it's not you. Like how in LOTR Aragorn has all the gifts (rightful heir, supersoldier, engaged to an immortal princess) but Sam is the real hero. I half wish Eliezer had used that approach in HPMOR instead of going with Harry as the obvious choice.
- teekert 11y agoI was aiming more towards the hyper-awareness aspect. The visualization of probabilities, the details that affect those probabilities, the fact that sometimes he is in the dark, a shadowy valley in which the horizons after which things are unknown are very close by (in the near future). I love that way of looking at it, it is an eye opener for me at this moment in time. I also don't like it that he dreamed he was going to be called Muad'Dib but I'm happy to ignore such small slips of the scientific pen and extract the value around it. By the way your post should have a spoiler alert ;) (Perhaps mine should as well)
- loup-vaillant 11y agoThere's a Naruto fanfic where the main character is actually Sakura. As expected, she's the weakest of the bunch. https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5193644/1/Time-Braid https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5193644/1/Time-Braid In the game Oblivion (Elder Scrolls IV), the player character is so much not the hero that he can't even wear the amulets of kings that is given to him at the very beginning of the game. The end of the main plot actually have you watch the messiah save the world. Unusual, but refreshing. (Then Skyrim went back to having the player being the messiah.)
- scott_s 11y agoI was enamored with Skyrim, but the more of the plot lines I went through, the more ridiculous the story seemed. So I'm the best warrior Companion, the best Mage in Winterhold, the key to the civil war and the dragon born? The first plot line I went through - Companions - worked fine, because it was the first. But each successive one fell flat at least a little, because how I was the best at everything. What I enjoyed was the world they built. The plot was secondary.
- logfromblammo 11y agoTo be fair, in Oblivion, you can still become the best thief, mage, fighter, gladiator, and assassin in the entire province, all at the same time. With the DLC, you can also become a holy knight and a copy of a daedric prince. Never mind the downloadable mods. I thought the point of that particular plot element--and making the player a prisoner of some sort at the beginning of Elder Scrolls games--was to avoid coercing the player into adhering to the preconceptions attached to particular roles. The game tells you, right from the start, that you're a blank slate, so do what you want. If you do all the quests, of course it's going to start being a bit ridiculous. But the game is also supposed to be fun for someone who wants to just play one particular role, without sinking 400 hours into the game while trying to do everything.
- bhaak 11y ago> Brave New World -> You can either spend time creating or you can spend it consuming. Interesting conclusion. In my interpretation, the lesson is more open ended: "You can be happy if you've found your niche but what if your ambitions don't match your abilities?" Most of the people in the society of Brave New World are fabricated to fit in and are happy and even for those few that don't fit in, the Controllers send them to small communities were they can be. Helmholtz is likely to be happy on his island and Mond himself is somewhat envious that Bernard will "meet the most interesting set of men and women to be found anywhere in the world". Bernard himself OTOH doesn't quite share this view. For good reasons as we know he feels superior to most people but actually isn't. And on the island it will be even more glaring.
- teekert 11y agoThe world in BNW does not like (innovative) creation, it is aimed at stability. You should do your job and enjoy mindlessly afterwards, either doing games or using somma. I.e.: "Ending is better than mending.", "...they're so conditioned that they practically can't help behaving as they ought to behave" -> Nowadays we have commercials to do that, the conditioning. Al least that is how I see it, many things we have nowadays can be extrapolated quite nicely into BNW. We do it to ourselves, by catering to our primal, short-term rewards systems we get less time to "create", instead we watch sitcoms. (I'm overreacting I bit, I know it's not so black and white.)
- bhaak 11y agoI agree that BNW's society is trying hard to be stable, like suppressing inventions that would give the lower castes to much free time. Our world has still problems that need to be solved and we are far from achieving a stable state. But in BNW, humanity has done that and now they (meaning most of humanity) want to keep that as they are happy with the status quo. In our world, just "consuming" instead of "creating" might be frowned upon but in BNW, is there really a need to create? Those who want, are allowed to, outside of the main society. It's not the kind of future society I would want to live in (no space travel, booo!) but if I'd have to choose a dystopia, BNW would probably be it.