3 ms·
This kinda seems like a recipe for boringly perfect, flaw-free characters.
by PhasmaFelis 11y ago
This kinda seems like a recipe for boringly perfect, flaw-free characters.
- endtime 11y agoI don't think this is even slightly true of the protagonists of the two most popular examples of the genre (Worm and HPMoR).
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoGlad to hear it, but the article writer hasn't conveyed it well. It really sounds like he's describing fiction about the clash of hyperrational superminds who aren't held back by petty things like "mistakes" or "emotions." Also--the article mainly uses the term "rationalist fiction," which is fine, but the title is "rational fiction," which is rather a turn-off. It reminds me of L. Ron Hubbard rattling on about how he doesn't write fantasy because fantasy is for stupids who can't write good, and he is a smart because he writes science fiction which is for smarts. The whole tone of the article is kind of self-congratulatory. If that doesn't reflect the actual stories, well, good.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoCharacters in rationalist fiction don't need to be without flaws. They need to be without the obvious, cliched flaws that make most fiction work. And in particular, this needs to be true of both the villains and the heroes, or you would indeed end up with something boring. The villains should have read the Evil Overlord List, and not make any of the obvious mistakes on it. Also see http://yudkowsky.tumblr.com/writing http://yudkowsky.tumblr.com/writing for a detailed guide specifically about writing characters in rationalist fiction.
- qznc 11y agoGame of throne's characters are very rational. The magic system (or lack of a system) makes it not quite fulfill the rational fiction definition.
- kijin 11y agoMany of the men in GoT who are closely involved in the power struggle are indeed quite rational. They have to be, since the less rational tend not to survive for long in that story. I can't say the same for the women, though. Most of the major female characters in GoT have a streak of crazy in them. Dany, Cersei, Lysa, Lady Stoneheart... The Tyrells seem to be the only exception.
- michaelt 11y agoTywin sends armies to torture villages looking for the brotherhood and burns crops despite knowing this is the last harvest before winter and food stocks are low. Most of the leaders in the war of five kings do the same thing - and get themselves killed to boot. We only see Lady Stoneheart kill perhaps half a dozen senior enemy commanders. I know who I think is being irrational...
- kijin 11y agoTywin burns crops because he wants the riverlands to starve. He is willing to destroy a large swath of the country in order to stay in power. It's a perfectly rational means to a despicable goal.
- saint_fiasco 11y agoI haven't read Game of Thrones so I'm probably missing some essential context. But in what universe is "destroying the country" a rational means and "stay in power" a despicable goal?