3 ms·
Well, it's a little unclear what course of action people are proposing. Political rants aren't that helpful. If people knew they could save a few bucks install
by melling 11y ago
Well, it's a little unclear what course of action people are proposing. Political rants aren't that helpful. If people knew they could save a few bucks installing solar they would. Consumers vote with their wallets.
Do we need to make solar cheaper or more efficient, for example? More battery research?
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoI think the course of action proposed by the comment is that "Political rants are useful", as demonstrated by the political rants that have made climate change as dubious as Evolution or "socialized" medicine in certain communities in direct contradiction of the facts. Solar is already cheap and efficient enough to be rolled out on a much wider scale than it currently is. It's a bit odd to be standing around and calling for more research when we are not bothering to fully exploit all the research that's already been done for reasons that are mostly political. As for the consumer being happy to pay, that's why the favourite wonk answer (implemented succesfully in a few countries) is a carbon tax to let the power of the free market do it's magic by accurately pricing in the externalities of carbon (and other greenhouse gasses). Right now you can find various studies claiming that shutting down coal power stations would save countries billions in health costs, but that's not the kind of "scandal" that makes it into the mainstream media, though every theoretical bird killed by a wind turbine is, strangely.
- melling 11y agoYou can't convince a significant percentage of the population that smoking is unhealthy. That Global warming is a problem, an even larger percentage. A study that shows X is practically meaningless isn't going to be persuasive. So, if solar is cheap and efficient we're going to need to do a little better at selling it. I don't see real numbers, just the unsubstantiated claim. Plus, I see the claim of a breakthrough on solar cell efficiency every couple of months on HN, which leads me to believe we're still waiting for one.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoYou can't convince a significant percentage of the population that smoking is unhealthy, because they've had literally decades of exposure to propaganda persuading them it makes them cool people. Also, it's physically addictive. Fossil fuels are much the same. There's an unbelievably vast propaganda and lobbying machine promoting the use of fossil fuels, even though - like smoking - they're killing our civilisation. This is why good government matters. It can provide a policy balance to destructive commercial self-interest. And solar is being rolled out, with very good economic results. It's even being rolled out successfully in the UK, which is not the sunniest place on the planet. In parts of the US it should literally be a no-brainer. But it's not, because most of the rich people who need fossil fuels to stay rich would rather kill it.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoThere are genuine solar breakthroughs every couple of months, its just the reporting that is garbled due to being dumbed down to science journalism standards. For example, something breaking a record in the lab doesn't mean its ready to be productized, or that it would be cost effective if it was, but we've got a great pipeline of improvements making their way to market. http://www.nrel.gov/ncpv/images/efficiency_chart.jpg http://www.nrel.gov/ncpv/images/efficiency_chart.jpg The recent MIT future of solar report is a good HN-level summary of where solar is now: https://mitei.mit.edu/futureofsolar https://mitei.mit.edu/futureofsolar It's not a sales pitch, but the people who are investing billions in solar these days aren't hippies, it's big business now, and they're convinced so the brainwashed masses will eventually twig they've been lied to.
- jonnycowboy 11y agoActually solar is so cheap right (real prices), that the price of the solar panels themselves (1$/Watt) are only 25-30% of the total installation cost (3-4$/watt). Inverters add onto that but over 50% of the cost is on the "soft" part of the installation (permits and labor). We need to innovate on the labor portion if we want to drop costs even more.
- icebraining 11y agoGallup poll: "In general, how harmful do you feel smoking is to adults who smoke?" Responses: - Very harmful: 80% - Somewhat harmful: 16% - Not too harmful: 3% . Not harmful at all: 1% http://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Production/Cms/POLL/udjnam5toesn5py9cqljfq.png http://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Prod... Where is the significant percentage not convinced that it's unhealthy?
- frobozz 11y agoIt can take about 10 years to recoup the initial outlay on a domestic solar installation, and after that you are actually saving money. The people saving the money are the residents of the property, and there is not enough confidence that the presence of solar panels increases the sale price of a property by the amount invested. So, if you are either a landlord or a first-time-buyer looking to trade up in a few years time, you won't invest in a domestic solar installation. Your money will give you a better ROI somewhere else over that period (e.g. buying your next property). Therefore, a political solution is probably desired. Something to reduce that 10-year period; something to encourage landlords to install solar; something to encourage first-time-buyers in particular to install.
- Shivetya 11y agowhich is why solar installations need to focus on the industrial scale instead of throwing money at individual home owners, which by the way excludes a significant number of people. There is zero reason to subsidize home owners installing wind or solar energy however you could get better results by subsidizing their purchase of power generated that way.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoThere's a few good reasons for residential rooftop solar, particularly in areas where the peak usage and sun coincide (where aircon is used for example). It not only dampens peak demand (the most expensive to serve) it can also delay the need for grid improvements required to deliver the peak demand. Progressive utilities consider it a win-win. I'm surprised landlords haven't jumped at the chance to add solar, they seem like exactly the kind of people who would invest up front for a guaranteed payback. I guess there must be some reason why it's not a standard thing, the difficulty of billing the renter for their electric use separately maybe?