3 ms·
I think they’re reading too much into the data. The inferences they’re drawing assume that the populations of “millenial men without kids” and “millenial men w
by jacobolus 11y ago
I think they’re reading too much into the data.
The inferences they’re drawing assume that the populations of “millenial men without kids” and “millenial men with kids” are part of an otherwise uniform group of millenial men, with attitudes changing as men go from one population into the other showing that pre-kid egalitarian attitudes couldn’t stand up to reality.
But this seems like an oversimplified model. There is a big selection bias when passing to the “men with children” group. It’s likely that men who get married and have children at a younger age probably tend to be from more religious backgrounds, for example.
To reliably make the kind of inferences the paper is making, you would need to survey men without children, wait a few years, then survey the same men after they had had children, and ignore the original interviews of men who still haven’t had children by the time of the second set of surveys.
Edit: I’m trying to track down the sources for this story, and it’s even more confusing, as from what I can tell they’re comparing numbers from different studies with different samples and methodologies. I really wish they would more concretely quote exactly which numbers were coming from which source.
- danieltillett 11y agoI am shocked - a published social science study with poor methodology and dubious analysis that fits the authors political biases. It is a good thing that this almost never happens.
- jacobolus 11y agoI haven’t read the cited studies in detail, and I wouldn’t say the studies themselves have poor methodology or dubious analysis until I’ve looked at them. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if the original studies made limited, well-qualified claims which were then exaggerated or taken out of context by the journalist. The main linked sources seem to be: http://asr.sagepub.com/content/80/1/116.abstract http://asr.sagepub.com/content/80/1/116.abstract (paywalled) and http://www.familiesandwork.org/times-are-changing-gender-and-generation-at-work-and-at-home/ http://www.familiesandwork.org/times-are-changing-gender-and... The second of those seems to mostly just report the data they found, without much editorializing. I’m slightly skeptical about the multiple regression at the end, but the rest of the findings are straight-forward to interpret. Other studies central to the article’s title argument are cited but not directly linked by the NYT as far as I can tell. I can’t find the mentioned surveys by the Center for Talent Innovation online anywhere; perhaps it’s pre-published data they discussed with the NYT journalist.
- danieltillett 11y agoI am even more shocked - you are telling me that journalists exaggerate! Next you will be telling me that they just make up stuff and pass it off as accurate and unbiased reporting. More seriously I have been an eyewitness to a number of events reported on by journalists over the years. Not a single one of these reports had any resemblance to what actually happened - I guess that is why they are called news stories and reporters hacks. Edit. Thanks for taking the time to track down the original papers. I should not be so harsh on social scientists as it is incredible hard to do any real science in this area. I could not design and run a social science study that had any scientific robustness or validity. There are just too many confounding variables and biases.