3 ms·
I don't see why automation means one must follow the "well-trodden path." Software isn't limited to a linear script. I'm no lawyer, but all those questions (wh
by icebraining 11y ago
I don't see why automation means one must follow the "well-trodden path." Software isn't limited to a linear script.
I'm no lawyer, but all those questions (where to incorporate, classes of stocks to use, etc) seem like they could be codified into decision trees and similar algorithms. I can see why a human would be better at learning and exploring to know what questions to ask, but surely applying them to a particular startup is mostly routine work?
- sandworm101 11y agoIf that were true then every business would be a Delaware corporation. Many are, but many aren't. No flowchart will get to every nuance.
- icebraining 11y agoWhy not? Assuming lawyers aren't working based on hunches, one should be able to write down the process followed, which could then be encoded in software (as a flow chart or otherwise). In fact, even if the lawyers are working from "instinct" and can't fully describe their process, it's just a matter of getting a good sample of existing companies (a few hundreds, perhaps, some of which not Delaware corps) and asking the lawyer to "fake advise" each one. At the end of the process, you'd have a pretty good model of that process.
- sandworm101 11y agoBecause, following the corp hypo, it isn't the lawyer's decision. A lawyer doesn't decide which path is best for a corporation. A lawyer outlines the various options and allows the corp's leaders to make the decision. Sometimes there is an obvious answer, sometimes not. Therefore any accurate flow chart would end with a series of options. The lawyer then stands ready to answer questions about those options. It's a back-and-forth conversation and, imho, the client rarely agrees completely with the lawyers opinion.
- rhino369 11y agoFor simple stuff, yea, an attorney could create a decision tree. But: 1) The hard part is objective and accurately assessing the issues at hand. I haven't done any legal work for startups, but I've done diligence on a few deals that involved a startup getting acquired or funded. I've seen several deals killed because some basic entrepreneurship issues were written off because the company thought it was no big deal. Nobody thinks they ripped off IP from their old company. But it's done, often unintentionally, all the time. So the decision tree would ask "Is your company using IP that you developed that is similar to your previous employer?" I can promise you that people who should answer yes, would be completely convinced that they should say no. Zuckerberg would have said no. And yet he had to pay HarvardConnect. 2) You are wasting the founders time thinking about this stuff. But I get the impulse. Law firms take their pound of flesh. I like Sandworms comment down thread about "legal debt."