5 ms·
What stops someone who is cheap to insure (like a retired person) taking out the insurance policy, then someone who is very expensive to insure (like someone wi
by chrisseaton 11y ago
What stops someone who is cheap to insure (like a retired person) taking out the insurance policy, then someone who is very expensive to insure (like someone with drink driving convictions) actually using the car all the time?
- ceejayoz 11y agoInsurance (in NY and OH, at least, I can't speak for other states/countries) asks who the primary driver is. If they can demonstrate you lied about that, I'd imagine they could retroactively drop you.
- justizin 11y agoNothing, really, but if that person gets into an accident, the insurance will probably be canceled immediately. When I was younger, my dad had my car on his insurance policy, but didn't tell me that it was cheaper because he said I lived at his address and only drove in the (rural) area he lived. When I had a minor collision in a parking lot, we both found ourselves without insurance.
- nadams 11y agoThat seems rather surprising they would drop you after one accident. I mean - if they were mad that you lied where you drove - how did they know that it wasn't a one time thing like visiting a friend? I would find it rather silly if you had to call your insurance company ahead and ask for their permission to drive outside of the area you said you would be driving in.
- mikeash 11y agoI imagine the troublesome bit was when the dad lied about where the kid lived. Residency can usually be proven or disproven, and where you live can affect your rates significantly.
- cmdrfred 11y agoCar insurance in the US is quite odd when you think about it. It's mandatory and if you don't live in a city so is a car so defacto you need to buy it. On top of that that doesn't actually cover your car! At the minimum level only cars you damage are covered so if you get hit by someone without insurance they are covered, you are not. Huge amounts of regulatory capture are involved and in my state (PA) it's almost impossible for someone to start their own car insurance company. I see plenty of room for disruption there. "In America you can buy a car for hundred dollars, but it costs a thousand to insure it" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pMHdGBz2AqI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pMHdGBz2AqI
- mikeash 11y agoWhat's odd about that? It would be weird if driving were a solitary activity, but when you drive you place significant risk on other people. You can easily use a car to cause damage that greatly exceeds what an average person can pay, so to ensure that you don't leave others in the lurch, they require you to carry liability insurance. They don't care one bit if you damage your own car beyond your ability to cover it, because that's your own problem. There's nothing weird about a $100 car costing $1000 to insure, because the insurance isn't about the $100 car, it's about the $20,000 (or $100,000) car you might crash into.
- cmdrfred 11y agoI just always felt a more equitable distribution of funds (as PA is a no fault state) is to have the people who have $100,000 cars to buy the insurance as they are the ones with the disposable income to afford it. The guy making 8 dollars an hour at Walmart with his 900 dollar beater isn't getting much value from that set up.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 11y agoWhat exactly would you propose should be done to place the burden on the guy with the $100,000 car? If you don't require that the guy with the beater buy insurance, all you're doing is setting him up to be bankrupted of whatever little he does have if he's at fault in an accident. And what if he crashes into another poor slob making $8 an hour at the Wal-Mart who managed to take out a loan to buy a slightly nicer car? Or what if he cripples that person for life, and they require constant medical care for decades? You're setting people up to be screwed a lot more than they need to be. (Note that the no-fault status of PA doesn't really matter here, because it just means that if both drivers have no-fault insurance, they can't sue the other driver for minor injuries. Property damage and serious injuries are still fair game.) If you do require insurance, but have the cost of the insurance scale neatly with the cost of the car it covers, then you'll either have a really low limit on liability which brings back all the problems above, or you'll need to subsidize the insurance somehow. Overall, it seems unfair to say that a person is allowed to put other people at significant risk for property damage and injury without paying for what that risk actually costs. If you don't like that this is more burdensome to the poor than to the rich, I think that more general schemes to alleviate poverty, like government assistance, are the way to go, because car insurance is only one of many, many ways that life is disproportionately expensive when you're poor.