3 ms·
This looks like all the same sort of stuff Google defaults you into on Android. I mean, not that it's any better because of that, but this is the state of thing
by moron4hire 11y ago
This looks like all the same sort of stuff Google defaults you into on Android. I mean, not that it's any better because of that, but this is the state of things now. You're not going to find better unless you install FOSS. Unless you're ready to go full-in on one of the BSDs or a Linux-that-isn't-Ubuntu, navigating the waters of figuring out how to get a phone that has all the features you want with such an OS, figuring out how to do all the work you need to do, then you're in for a penny, in for a pound.
Apple, Google, Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, the FBI, NSA, CIA, DHS, they all have my data already. Thanks to OPM, the Russians and Chinese probably have my data now, too. What does it matter if Microsoft has it? They probably already have it. Maybe it's even better to make sure everyone has my data, rather than allowing it to be used as a competitive advantage by one or a small set of corporations. Cat's out of the bag. Horses have left the stable. Whatever other metaphors you want to throw in there.
So decide, and decide now: either go full-in on FOSS, or shut up and eat your cookie. Otherwise, this exercise hasn't been about privacy, it's been about anti-Bill-Gates-and-Steve-Ballmer-Microsoft sentiment.
- joosters 11y agoIf there are reasonable opt-outs, then you can have your cake and eat it without jumping ship to Linux/FOSS. (And, to a lesser extent, you might face the same problems there, e.g. with Ubuntu) The problem is that with all platforms, the opt outs are hard to find and, even worse, hard to even know when the opt outs even exist.
- pdkl95 11y agoOpting out still leaves all the non-technical people who don't know about or understand the opt-out to whatever abuse MS (et al) wants to put in the OS? Worse, you are still financially supporting these decisions by either buying the OS or adding to the usage counts. By "opting out" while still using the OS, you're still asking for more of this crap in the future.
- rifung 11y agoExcuse me if I just don't fully comprehend your argument, but isn't FOSS an orthogonal issue to this? After all, even if software is open source, that doesn't stop it from mining your data. You just know that they are doing so. I suppose you can remove that feature, but it seems you're also able to disable the features here as well. In any case, I'm all for FOSS but it doesn't seem to be a solution to this problem, which admittedly, is not even really a problem to everyone.
- moron4hire 11y agoYes, I agree that it's not really a problem for everyone. The issue isn't actually privacy. The issue is "find a reason to bash on MS for this month". Now, I think the incentive structures for FOSS projects are a little different such that the FOSS environment isn't going to converge on the idea of collecting such data. But clearly, throw any sort of system that wants to make money into the mix, coupled with the fact that users just refuse to pay for software anymore, and every giganto corp from Mozilla to Canonical are going to independently come to the same conclusion of collecting this sort of data. The problem is not that privacy is important. The problem is that privacy isn't as important to people as not having to pay cash for software. So the people who are complaining about this are never going to be happy with anything Microsoft does. Either MS collects too much data, or they are tone-deaf to the market and aren't keeping up with cutting edge features. Either MS "hides" non-default settings, or they are falling behind in the state of the art of UI design. I mean, Apple or Google wouldn't have even given you the little link that people have been complaining about as "hidden", even though it's right there on the screen. They would have expected you to hunt the setting down in some settings dialog somewhere. What MS has done here is standard MS UI design theory, has been for over two decades. But it's cool to bash on MS. And the only way such people are going to be satisfied and stay consistent, is to completely bail out of any software where anyone involved has a need to make income.
- saiya-jin 11y agoapple and google are scumbag corporations (not only) when it comes to privacy... so is it OK if another big corp joins them? you basically say yes, I say NO.
- briandear 11y agoOne big advantage I get from my Mac OS over FOSS solutions is that they have an incentive to constantly improve their product. Do you know a single professional designer using a FOSS Illustrator? How about the FOSS version of Keynote? Or the FOSS version of Final Cut and Logic? FOSS isn't the answer to every question. FOSS is like a city bus; reliable enough, cheap enough for everyone and goes mostly where you want to go despite the occasional smell or sleeping vagrant sprawled across the seats. However, it certainly doesn't compare to driving your own Mercedes. FOSS is certainly great, but it isn't the end all be all, despite utopian hippie delusions to the contrary.