3 ms·
>> The license you propose is NOT FREE SOFTWARE. I am astounded the OSI has gone and decided to become an organization that just rubber stamps things which are
by phkahler 11y ago
>> The license you propose is NOT FREE SOFTWARE. I am astounded the OSI
has gone and decided to become an organization that just rubber stamps
things which are not free. I don't know who they are talking to, but
these "licenses" which they approve are chock full of constraints
against various segments of the user community.
OSI is not about free software. It's not even very good about open source. They seemed happy if people had access to the source code regardless of the terms around it. They approved lots of licenses that had crap in them.
IMHO BSD/MIT or GPL/LGPL are pretty much it. If you need a different license than those, you've probably got an agenda. OSI gave a rubber stamp to different agendas.
- candeira 11y agoPlease point one single OSI-approved license that is not free by the FSF's Free Software Definition and/or the Debian Free Software Guidelines. I'd be delighted to learn something I don't know. I asked Stallman once, and he could only remember a case where OSI messed up and then fixed it when they realised.
- phkahler 11y agoWell this is turning into a lesson for me. There are a few that used to be non-free until newer versions came along: Apple Public Source License - was nonfree before 2.0 Artistic License 1.0 was nonfree. 2.0 is. Reciprocal Public License - FSF doesn't indicate a revision, but OSI shows a version 1.5. Without history it's not clear weather these were OSI approved before revision. There are also some in the OSI list that are not on the FSF list, so I'm not sure if they're free or not. But I still stand by my second assertion that most of them are unnecessary. If you're not BSD/MIT compatible and not GPL/LGPL compatible, your code will probably have a limited life.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Without history it's not clear weather these were OSI approved before revision. OSI has history. All licenses approved by OSI are either on the current list [0] or the superceded list (where the originator of the OSI-approved licenses has indicated it should not be used for new work) [1]. [0] http://opensource.org/licenses/alphabetical http://opensource.org/licenses/alphabetical [1] http://opensource.org/licenses/do-not-use http://opensource.org/licenses/do-not-use
- dragonwriter 11y ago> OSI is not about free software. It's not even very good about open source. They seemed happy if people had access to the source code regardless of the terms around it. They approved lots of licenses that had crap in them. The last sentence isn't true unless the FSF has also done so; there aren't lots of OSI-approved Open Source licenses that aren't also blessed by the FSF as Free Software licenses (the same is true in reverse, as well.)