3 ms·
Unless I am missing some hidden biases this seems an interesting discussion with some worthwhile thinking material. It does not seem like a "rape apologist", w
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
Unless I am missing some hidden biases this seems an interesting discussion with some worthwhile thinking material. It does not seem like a "rape apologist", whatever that is.
For me the main argument is a big one::
When the California Corrections Department recently examined cases of sex offender registrants returned to prison for a new offense, they found that in 88% of the cases, the new offense was a parole violation. Parole violations are generally acts that aren’t crimes for anyone not on parole—things like going to a bar or visiting a friend who’s also an ex-felon. Only 1.8% of those re-incarcerated had committed a new sex offense.
That's a really big mis step in defining recidivist rates - and I would think it is worth following up in all cases (not just sex offences)
- fweespeech 11y agoEh, I'd say the bigger bit is compared to all ex-felons: > About 3% of felons with no known history of sex offenses commit one within 4.5 years of their release. Its pretty clear: To justify having a subset of ex-felons [sex offenders] on the list, all ex-felons have to be on the list. Otherwise, the justification [they are sex offenders] falls flat when other types of ex-felons commit sex offenses more frequently. Honestly, it sounds like a publicly auditable and widely accessible list of felons is likely what we need if we consider 1.8% reason to put people on a list.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoOk I get your point, and you seem to be arguing the same as the article - the value of a register of sex offenders is not as great as it might seem. it depends I suppose on whether the register has much of an effect. I mean if you reoffend even after going to jail, having your name on a list seems unlikely to help.
- fweespeech 11y agoIt isn't identical to the article. I think there needs to be a list of convicted felons somewhere that is widely accessible with their addresses so people are aware they are in the neighborhood. However, I don't think it should list them as "sex offenders" or the like. There is an unearned stigma in many of the cases. [e.g. urinating in public gets you on THE LIST]
- mucker 11y agoI found this quote in particular to be troubling for the _opposite_ reason. That is, in the case of a sex offender who is a pederast, hanging out with a child can be (and for good reason) a parole offense. The author buries this in his argument in order to hide the information from the audience.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoI had not actually considered that. I would then look at reforms of the parole system. In the same way there is murder and manslaughter, there is hanging round school gates and drinking in a bar with other felons. But yes, good point. Inwonder how the parole violations are recorded?