3 ms·
This isn't as rare as I would like it. A few gun studies from the west coast in the 90's pulled this kind of quote without justification or attribution. Two a
by protomyth 11y ago
This isn't as rare as I would like it. A few gun studies from the west coast in the 90's pulled this kind of quote without justification or attribution.
Two additional things to be aware of are conditions of the study and people pulling a statistic without the full qualification.
"This activity reduced X by 50%" is a popular one. It gets used when writing grants, but often the original study had very specific environmental conditions to go along with that reduction. Those are often ignored in the activities spread.
Quite a lot of people pull quotes from even legitimate studies, but forget to also pull the qualifiers. This happens a lot with medical studies.
There is another, but I can hardly blame people giving its an outright deception. Sometime government agencies or individuals falsify data. We all remember the whole vaccine thing and the damage it did. I can now blame folks for repeating this long after the facts are know.
A popular one I've seen on HN is people quoting AMTRAK's budget showing AMTRAK's ACELA Express is profitable. Sadly, that's only true if you use some really shady accounting[1] and completely forget capital costs. You wouldn't know that from the various articles quoting the actual budget report.
Politics sometimes trumps the doing of basic fact checking.
1) here is one of the internal critiques of even the newer accounting https://www.oig.dot.gov/sites/default/files/Amtrak's%20New%20Cost%20Accounting%20System%20Report%5E3-27-13.pdf https://www.oig.dot.gov/sites/default/files/Amtrak's%20New%2... and http://www.amtrak.com/ccurl/782/517/Amtrak-Report-on-Internal-Control-Over-Financial-Reporting-2013.pdf http://www.amtrak.com/ccurl/782/517/Amtrak-Report-on-Interna...
- bmelton 11y agoI've (sadly) conditioned myself to reading post hoc ergo propter hoc statements as effectively useless in today's time. There are some statements that I suspect make intuitive conclusions, and many of which I suspect are right (e.g., availability of birth control lowers the rate of abortions and unplanned pregnancies), but even those with which I agree are relegated to the portion of my mind that holds the "do not recite this" category of statistics. I understand why people are so susceptible to it, and indeed, what makes the scientific method so damn hard to being with, is because isolation and controls in the real world are indeed very hard to come by, but I do wish that it was something we could do less.