3 ms·
Words do cause harm. It's a failure of imagination to think otherwise. When you use the word retard you dehumanise people with LD. You contribute to a culture
by DanBC 11y ago
Words do cause harm. It's a failure of imagination to think otherwise.
When you use the word retard you dehumanise people with LD. You contribute to a culture where it's okay to deny those people work; to segregate them in specialist housing; to deny them medical treatment; to kill them with lack of medical treatment.
It's a slippery slope to eugenics and genocide to think otherwise.
- sklogic 11y ago> When you use the word retard you dehumanise people with LD. No. When I use the word "retard" I'm pointing out on a lack of mental ability demonstrated by a particular person. And I do not even want to discuss anything that contains the SJW newspeak like "dehumanise", "empower", "exclude" and all that crap. > You contribute to a culture where it's okay to deny those people work; to segregate them in specialist housing; to deny them medical treatment; to kill them with lack of medical treatment. Your imagination is likely boosted by an illegal substances abuse. > It's a slippery slope to eugenics Yes, another victim of the early SJWs. There is nothing wrong with the idea of eugenics per se, problems arise with its potential uses. I admire the eugenics efforts of Singapore, for example, and will be delighted to see where it all goes. > and genocide to think otherwise. It's a bullshit scaremongering to put these two words in one sentence.
- DanBC 11y agoPeople with learning disability have been the target of eugenics in various forms. They've been subjected to sterilisation sometimes without their knowledge and sometimes against their will. They've been interned in segregated care homes. They've been murdered - either directly killed because they have LD or allowed to die by doctors refusing to provide medical care or placing DNR notices without the patient's (or their family's) knowledge and consent. They've been shot and killed by police who lack skills to work woth people with LD. People with LD were used as subjects of medical experimentation against their will and without their knowledge. They were told they were being innoculated against hepititus when they were being infected with hepititus. (This was in the 1970s, a long time after Nürnburg Code and after Helsinki agreement). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Willowbrook_State_School https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Willowbrook_State_School Hundreds of thousands of learning disabled people have been killed purely because they have a learning disability. I stand by the genocide claim.
- sklogic 11y agoAnd how exactly did you manage to draw a connection between these outrageous facts and a use of an innocent derogatory language?
- DanBC 11y agoIt's not "innocent derogatory language". "Cockroach" is just a word. Cockroach was used to dehumanise Tutsi in Rawanda. Use of that language was a small part of the genocide of Tutsi by Hutu majority. We see similar dehumanising language in other genocidal actions: it's present in Nazi Germany when they describe Jewish people as subhuman - the same word has been used against people with LD. Not just by the Nazis with their T4 program[1] but also by British eugenics supporters.[2] these eugenic attitudes lost popularity after the war, but they were still easy enough to find. And apart from these dehumanising effects the word is used to creat fear, alarm, and distress among the people it's used against. People are routinely attacked with that word. If you think words can't hurt i) you've had a cushy life and ii) you spectacularly lack imagination and empathy. Really: learn to English and come up with better insults. [1] http://www.ushmm.org/outreach/en/article.php?ModuleId=10007683 http://www.ushmm.org/outreach/en/article.php?ModuleId=100076... [2] http://www.newstatesman.com/society/2010/12/british-eugenics-disabled http://www.newstatesman.com/society/2010/12/british-eugenics...
- sklogic 11y agoLeanr a bit of logic. This is nowhere near a proof that a use of a certain language is a direct or indirect cause of a genocide and not just a symptom, and that censoring this language would have stopped the genocide. Not to mention that now it seems to be a priviledge of the self-righteous SJWs to proclaim which words should be counted as offensive this week. It never comes from the minorities in question.
- DanBC 11y ago> Not to mention that now it seems to be a priviledge of the self-righteous SJWs to proclaim which words should be counted as offensive this week. It never comes from the minorities in question. You're wrong. Use of the word retard has been strongly rejected by people with a learning disability in the UK. The word disability has also been rejected, which is why I use LD for learning difficulties, or I use specific diagnoses for granularity. They have rejected these terms for many years. The change in language is something they have been driving.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jazzyk 11y agoYou guys may be thinking about two different contexts: 1. calling someone with a disability a retard (which I would never, ever do) 2. using the word "retarded" in a generic sense. For example: I may have called my kids retarded, in exasperation, for doing something nonsensical. Not elegant, but has been used as a figure of speech, of sorts, for ever. My problem with censoring words (and political correctness in general) is that it is an overly simplistic intent to make the world a gentler place - even if you forbid people from saying/writing certain words, you will not change how they think/behave. Nobody dares to use the n... word, but there are still a lot of racists (and reverse-racists, it needs to be said) out there. The only way to fix it is education and culture - no other way around it.
- MichaelGG 11y ago1. How long ago was it that "retarded" was the socially acceptable term? 2. What is a "reverse" racist?
- DanBC 11y agoYour child is eating something. You ask if you can try a bit. They laughingly say "no way! These are mine!" Do you then continue the joke? "stop being such a Jew! Give me a chip!" Are you saying it's fine to use that word because it's just a joke? It's not a serious insult?
- jazzyk 11y agoNo, it is not fine to use what you described. The difference is that you are picking on a particular nationality, while "retarded" is a generic term meaning "mentally under-developed" which, while certainly not a term of endearment, may apply to any human.
- DanBC 11y agoI don't understand your point. Why is it not okay to use the word Jew as an insult against non-Jews, while it's fine to use the word retard as an insult against non-retards?
- plonh 11y agoDo you support banning all github projects that use the word "insane"? I assume you must, to be consistent in your morals.
- DanBC 11y agoI support github banning all projects that use the word "pickle" or "umbrella" or "orange". Their servers, their rules. I'm less touchy about mental illness words. I tend notto say anything when they're used. I sometimes say something if people (wrongly) link mental illness to violence. There has been more time for insane etc to change use.
- iopq 11y agoYour words caused harm to me, could you delete your comment? I am very offended.
- DanBC 11y agoSure. Show me where words I use have been used by, for example, Nazis when testing their mass killing mechanisms before moving onto Jews and homosexuals. Or where my words have been used to deny people medical treatment; sometime causing the death of those people. Or where my words have been used in hate crime or hate incidents. (Hate incidents based on disability are more common than anti-Semitism in the UK, and anti Semitism is pretty common over here). Show me the harm and I'll gladly chose differet words.
- iopq 11y agoYou just don't understand, because you're privileged. It's a waste of my time to explain something so obvious to a shitlord like you. Apologize for what you did!