3 ms·
It's about a company acting in a way that is alienating to its userbase. Wouldn't that depend on the userbase? If there are more people using Github who would
by onion2k 11y ago
It's about a company acting in a way that is alienating to its userbase.
Wouldn't that depend on the userbase? If there are more people using Github who would prefer it was a sanitized environment than people who think anything should be allowed then Github removing this content would be them acting not to alienate its userbase. The majority of users probably don't care either way, so we're only talking about the two extremes - and I'd hazard a guess that there are far more people who would rather Github didn't have an "anything goes" policy than did.
- bad_user 11y agoHow do you know that the majority of users don't care? Did you or anybody else run any surveys or was that thought pulled out of your ass? I'm hearing this argument a lot on HN, yet it is never accompanied by numbers and because it's always contrary to my experience. Would you say the same thing about Sourceforge? Of course, there's a difference between piggybacking on the work of others to distribute malware and censoring some words, however there's also similarity. GitHub censoring content means they are not a neutral platform for hosting public repositories and they are showing their potential for becoming the next Sourceforge.
- onion2k 11y agoGitHub censoring content means they are not a neutral platform for hosting public repositories and they are showing their potential for becoming the next Sourceforge. In the same way that because I punched my brother as a child I might go on to be the next Stalin.
- bad_user 11y agoPunching your brother doesn't make you Stalin, but it's still an action you have to apologize for, otherwise you're an asshole, hence my argument.
- onion2k 11y agoAs you say, punching your brother doesn't make you Stalin, just as requesting a repo changes it's name doesn't mean you'll go on to infect all the downloads with malware.