3 ms·
Should Facebook not allow "Robert Galbraith" (JK Rowling) to have a page? How about "JK Rowling" (Joanne Rowling)? Should she be forced to use her full forename
by DanBC 11y ago
Should Facebook not allow "Robert Galbraith" (JK Rowling) to have a page? How about "JK Rowling" (Joanne Rowling)? Should she be forced to use her full forename?
In England you can use whatever name you like, as long as you don't have the intent to deceive. (This is tricky with doctors and banks). So, legally, I could be "Bob Smith" and "Ann Jones" at the same time. Why does Facebook get to tell me that I only have one name when my government is fine with me having multiple names?
- zaidf 11y agoWhy does Facebook get to tell me that I only have one name when my government is fine with me having multiple names? Because Facebook isn't your government. It is a non-government entity with a very specific vision. If it finds that the use of fake names hinders the experience of other users and there by Facebook Corp., it should be allowed to require real names.
- Symbiote 11y agoIf it finds that allowing black people to use the service hinders the experience of other users, should it be allowed to block them?
- CHY872 11y agoAt the moment it is illegal for them to do such a thing (at least in the US) for black people are a protected group (civil rights act etc). Other than for a small number of reasons due to protected groups, businesses generally have the right to refuse business to anyone for any reason. Do I think Facebook should be allowed to block black people? No. Do I think Facebook should be allowed to block pseudonyms? Yes.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoWhy would that ever be the case?
- florian-f 11y agoIs there a British version of the [Lichtbildausweis](https://shop.digitalcourage.de/lng/en/thema/ak-data-retension/lichtbildausweis-mit-selbst-gewaehlten-daten.html?type=N&language=en https://shop.digitalcourage.de/lng/en/thema/ak-data-retensio...)? It's a custom 'official' looking ID that is sold by an NGO that promotes privacy among other things.
- Symbiote 11y agoNo, but probably because there's no official identity card in Britain. I've never tried to use a false name, but it probably would be easy for many things (utilities, local government) but difficult for others (bank account).
- juliangregorian 11y agoNot even a driver's license?
- jameshart 11y agoDriver's licenses, passports, utility bills, bank cards, all are considered 'forms of ID' in the UK, which you might need to use to open a bank account or get credit, but there's no 'ID card'; there's no obligation to have a driving license, or a passport, or whatever.
- juliangregorian 11y agoThat much is true in the US as well.