4 ms·
...according to a rumor posted in a comment on another blog. I'd say there's basically no chance of this being accurate. Otherwise, I'd buy a case of phones an
by eli 17y ago
...according to a rumor posted in a comment on another blog.
I'd say there's basically no chance of this being accurate. Otherwise, I'd buy a case of phones and resell them for parts. They surely cost at least $300 to produce just in parts.
- ynniv 17y agoI'd say there's basically no chance of this being accurate. Otherwise, I'd buy a case of phones and resell them for parts. They surely cost at least $300 to produce just in parts. Hmm, the iPhone 3GS teardown is only supposed to be ~ $175. I haven't seen any reason to suspect that the Nexus One is more expensive hardware. Not to mention that whoever posted this clearly doesn't understand Google Voice (hint: it's not a VoIP endpoint) Sure it is - you just use POTS to access it right now. I wouldn't get too caught up in product details, when there is no technical reason to prevent it.
- smokey_the_bear 17y agoAnd Google just bought Gizmo, which is a Voip endpoint. It already had some Google Voice integration, presumably it'll have more when they relaunch.
- psranga 17y agoSounds pretty believable and reasonable to me (except for launch date). Do you have further info on why the phone will cost about $300 to build? In comparison, the iPhone 3GS allegedly has BOM of $178. http://www.isuppli.com/News/Pages/iPhone-3G-S-Carries-178-96-BOM-and-Manufacturing-Cost-iSuppli-Teardown-Reveals.aspx http://www.isuppli.com/News/Pages/iPhone-3G-S-Carries-178-96... Curious here: who would buy the "parts"? It'll cost you a lot just to disassemble the phone.
- eli 17y agoI don't put a ton of faith in iSuppli, but regardless my point is that it is unlikely anyone would sell a device at a loss--and $99 would surely be a loss, yes?--without any obvious way to recoup that money.
- jonknee 17y agoMaking an open source mobile OS isn't a great way to make money either. Google sees mobile as critical to long-term success and is spending money to make big inroads. If they spend a billion dollars and get 20,000,000 new people as Google mobile users that may be a coup in the future. Hell, they spent more than that for YouTube.
- jmonegro 17y agoAs I mentioned in a previous comment, they know they'll make tremendous amounts of money from mobile search, and app sales (if/when they pick up for android). Over a year, everyone with android will probably have supplied Google with hundreds of dollars of mobile search revenue. If the Gphone sells for a low price, and in very high quantities, they will probably lose for every one sold, but will make much more per user than the $100-200 lost on production. It also means more sticky users in the long run, popularizing android and turning more people towards google. More apps would be developed, other android phones will presumably sell more (unless the contrary happens, in which case it is the Gphone that sells, which means even more money for Google).
- eli 17y agoI wonder, how many thousands of mobile ads would I have to click on to generate $100 for Google?
- freetard 17y agoYou don't have to click ads, they pay by impression too.
- jmonegro 17y agotrue, you don't have to click them: every website you visit on android that has Google ads on it, or YouTube (more ads) would generate revenue to Google just by visiting it. Plus, some ads run for over $20+ per click, out of which Google surely makes a nice chunk out of, which means that, by these parameters combined, you don't really have to click many ads to generate $100 for Google. I reckon that over the course of a year (the average length of time at which users change their phones), you'd generate Google more (if not much more) than $100 in explicit and implicit revenue.
- philwelch 17y agoParts alone are probably closer to $200, but $300 is a more realistic break-even point when you add in manufacturing costs, all the shipping that has to take place, and the fixed engineering costs.
- vaporstun 17y agoAlso worth noting, while Apple prices theirs higher because they make money on the actual handset, Google makes money on every smartphone that gets into the hands of a user from the ad revenue. Get enough smartphones into the hands of users and Google will see their revenues increase from the increased viewing of ads. So they needn't sell the phone at such a high margin to make a profit.
- mrkurt 17y agoReally? The iPod touch is $199. Cell radios really aren't that expensive.
- eli 17y agoYet the iPhone costs more than twice that. And the ADP1 (an unlocked G1) has relatively modest specs compared to this new phone and costs $400 from Google. I don't think that's because Google is trying to make a mint by sticking it to developers. Virtually all new HTC smartphones retail in the $400-600 range. I don't think HTC is making a fortune off them.
- jmonegro 17y agoBecause apple is pretty greedy, and the iPhone has a camera.
- ricardo 17y agoApple is setting a price that millions of people are willing to pay. I wouldn't call that greed.
- foldr 17y agoWhat would you call greed, then?
- CamperBob 17y agoSetting a price that's more than what your product is worth in the marketplace. You can always spot real 'greed' because it's always self-defeating in the end.
- jmonegro 17y agoJust because they're selling at market price, it doesn't mean that they're not greedy. If they were a bit less greedy, they'd rather have more users for a lower price, which in the long run can actually result in the same revenue. But then I'd get into the luxury brands theory/subject, but meh.
- jmonegro 17y agoIt doesn't matter: Google knows it will make good money from mobile search, and if the offer those phones at a market-shattering price, in which the will sell it in volumes, they will more than make up for what they lost in the first place.
- chrischen 17y agoYou know the ps3 cost in excess of 800 to manufacture at launch, and sold for around 400. The us army/navy, forgot which, bought a bunch of ps3s to harvest the cell processor. But that doesn't mean that's what most people do. Xbox Also cost more to produce, but I haven't heard of anyone selling it's parts.
- ryanelkins 17y agoYeah I was about to write about this. Those consoles were sold at a loss because they could make up the difference and then some on game sales (through licensing or however that works). The qestion then becomes how would Google monetize these phone users? Do they listen to our phone calls or text messages and send us even more targeted ads? Are they looking to monetize voice communication they way they did email? In order to sell at a loss they have to be making it up somewhere.
- encoderer 17y agoIt wasn't just game sales. Bill Gates has seen the need and value of a PC underneath everyones TV since at least 1995. Set top box software. Web TV. Etc. Xbox is the next step in that strategy. Sony saw the same thing. And this is no different, I don't think. Google sees value in putting accessibility to its services in everyones pockets.
- dskhatri 17y agoWhere are you getting the $300 figure from? Also, elsewhere in this discussion you say "Yet the iPhone costs more than twice that" (ie >$400, [1]). iSuppli estimates the cost to be $180 including manufacturing and "other" parts[2]. This is very much in line with Apple's typical margins. Apple doesn't sell commodity products so it's no surprise that they could be netting 50% margins (see [3] for iPod cost information). I work in the electronic components industry. The component costs quoted by iSuppli are credible. Companies like Samsung and Apple are able to negotiate very low prices for components from their suppliers. The suppliers are willing to offer components at lower prices and hence sacrifice their profit margins for a couple of reasons: (a) Apple and Samsung buy in large volume (b) Apple and Samsung will always be around. Offering the best prices now is a foot in the door for future business with them [1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=996710 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=996710 [2] http://gigaom.com/2009/12/09/who-is-getting-rich-off-the-iphone/ http://gigaom.com/2009/12/09/who-is-getting-rich-off-the-iph... [3] http://www.businessweek.com/technology/content/sep2005/tc20050921_4557.htm?campaign_id=rss_tech http://www.businessweek.com/technology/content/sep2005/tc200...
- roc 17y agoThey're reportedly unlocked, but still each require a $30/mo, 24 month T-Mobile data contract. You'd have to make quite a bit on those parts to cover the subscription costs.