4 ms·
I don't want to address the difference between civilian and military pilots, since I think the author has done a fine job of that. But I would like to point ou
by mcguire 11y ago
I don't want to address the difference between civilian and military pilots, since I think the author has done a fine job of that.
But I would like to point out that see-and-avoid doesn't really work in general, and particularly not in the case of two small aircraft with wildly different performance characteristics. I suspect that, even if the F-16 was on a practice instrument approach, the bottom of its performance envelope is significantly higher than the top of the Cessna 150's. (According to the 'pedia, maximum speed is 109kt and Vne is 140kt.)
See-and-avoid has been the first and more-or-less primary anti-collision system in aviation use, but if you've ever tried to cross a highway with high-speed oncoming traffic, you've probably already learned that there are limits to the human visual system. It's just not built to do that sort of thing. No doubt keeping your head outside the cockpit does prevent a lot of crashes, but expecting it to have prevented any crash, much less this one, is too much of a reach.
Keep in mind that most animal's visual systems are pretty good at picking up movement, but one of the signs that you are on a collision course with another vehicle is that it isn't moving in you visual field.
From [1]: "[The University of Washington’s Autonomous Flight System Lab] came up with a novel way to [modeled the UAS collision risk], reasoning that the known behavior (and random collisions) of gas molecules could serve as a way to predict collision probabilities between VFR aircraft, including UAS. (PDF)[3] To test the hypothesis, they compared the gas-molecule data to actual midair collision data and found a remarkably good fit. This allows two conclusions: manned airplanes under VFR run into each other at about the same random rate as gas molecules do and that’s pretty strong statistical evidence that see and avoid doesn’t work. (Because of a variance between the gas data and actual midairs, the paper concluded that see and avoid might work 14 percent of the time, but a bit better during the past few years. Possibly for a reason.)"
By the way, [1] is an entertaining post with some information, while [2] is a paper from 'stralia called, "Limitations of the See-and-Avoid Principle".
[1] http://www.avweb.com/blogs/insider/Why-See-and-Avoid-Doesnt-Work-223680-1.html http://www.avweb.com/blogs/insider/Why-See-and-Avoid-Doesnt-...
[2] http://www.skybrary.aero/bookshelf/books/259.pdf http://www.skybrary.aero/bookshelf/books/259.pdf
[3] https://www.aa.washington.edu/research/afsl/publications/lum_risk_for_uavs_2010_2.pdf https://www.aa.washington.edu/research/afsl/publications/lum...
Ps. Ok, I do want to say something about the difference between military and civilian pilots. Back in 2004, six soldiers and a general died when a Blackhawk hit a television transmission tower guy wire while in heavy fog.[4] The tower was 1800 feet tall; apparently the helicopter hit the wire about half way up. It wasn't a training mission; the helicopter was "headed to Red River to check maintenance on equipment". The first question from me, the most holster-sniffing of non-pilots, was, "What was he doing flying below 1000 feet in heavy fog?"
[4] http://www.chron.com/news/houston-texas/article/Seven-soldiers-from-Fort-Hood-killed-in-Texas-1964766.php http://www.chron.com/news/houston-texas/article/Seven-soldie...
- fnordfnordfnord 11y ago>But I would like to point out that see-and-avoid doesn't really work in general, and particularly not in the case of two small aircraft with wildly different performance characteristics. This^. I was right-seat in a King Air and heard Center call traffic for us at 1/4 mile, looked once, nothing, turned head in case I might have lost my bearing, looked again and there it was. I felt I could almost read the numbers and ID on the aircraft, that's an exaggeration, but it was close. If there hadn't also been some altitude separation, we could've been in a lot worse shape because we were under the other A/C's nose. Neither myself nor the pilot could see it before it was already very close, and it closed too fast for us to do much because we didn't have much energy (climbing spiral with skydivers on board).