3 ms·
Would this be easy to scam if I know in advance that my income will be decreasing, especially if it will decrease incrementally? EDIT: This is almost the equiv
by slg 11y ago
Would this be easy to scam if I know in advance that my income will be decreasing, especially if it will decrease incrementally?
EDIT: This is almost the equivalent of paycheck insurance. Like most insurance companies, I imagine Even makes money off of float [1]. However, insurance companies are also great at modeling their customers' risk. I don't see how Even could accomplish that. It is a natural information asymmetry and I'm not sure how Even could have a better idea of a customer's future earning then the customer.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Float_(money_supply) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Float_(money_supply)
- sanderjd 11y agoI was pretty surprised to see they're charging $3 because I figured they would give it away "for free" and make money on the float.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Would this be easy to scam if I know in advance that my income will be decreasing, especially if it will decrease incrementally? They're using a non-disclosed algorithm to calculate an "average" that's not really an average, and holding on to all the money above that, and charging you $3/week for the privilege. If they haven't already constructed the algorithm so that its nearly impossible for them to ever be giving you a "boost" other than from your own deferred wages that they are holding on to, I'd be surprised. > However, the insurance companies are also great at modeling their customer's risk. Insurance companies also have to disclose the terms and conditions, including, particularly, the specific events that qualify for a payout and the amount of the payout; Even does not disclose this. > It is a natural information assymetry and I'm not sure how Even could have a better idea of a customer's future earning then the customer. Because of the non-disclosed "average" algorithm, there's an additional -- and potentially more significant -- information asymmetry working in the opposite direction of the one you describe.
- slg 11y agoThen they are almost assuredly in violation of some type of regulation. They can't just charge interest, call it a proprietary average algorithm and avoid all the regulation regarding publishing interest rates and such. Also their about page is throwing red flags in regards to regulation. First off, it doesn't look like anyone involved has experience in either finance or the law. Secondly it says "We're not bankers. We're not a payday lender or a credit card company." That isn't up to Even, that is up to the law and this sounds a lot like those laws are being completely ignored.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Then they are almost assuredly in violation of some type of regulation. Quite possibly, not like they'd be the first startup to do that as a core feature of their business model. > They can't just charge interest, call it a proprietary average algorithm and avoid all the regulation regarding publishing interest rates and such. Sure, but what they're actually doing is charging interest on loans, they are holding money from your paycheck as a deposit before you need the loan, using the undisclosed proprietary "average" algorithm. Then using the same algorithm to determine when you are due a "boost", and paying that boost to you out of your own deposits that have been kept from prior paychecks, only giving you an interest-free advance if their undisclosed algorithm says you are due a boost and you have exhausted the deposits previously held-back from your pay by the same algorithm. The customer's superior knowledge of their likely future income situation can't be used to game the system without knowledge of the algorithm which sets the rules of the game.
- slg 11y agoTrue, I guess it entirely depends on their average algorithm. However, if they are paying the boosts out of previously saved money then they this a managed bank account. If they are paying the boost on the assumption that it will be paid off in the future then they this is a loan. Either one is required to spell out the exact terms in a clearer way than Even's very simplistic FAQ page. It just rubs me the wrong way that too often these days disruption amounts to "I am going to go in to X line of business, ignore the law, and pocket all the money any competitor would have to pay to comply with regulations."
- run4yourlives2 11y agoI'm assuming they've done enough math on this that they know the overall break even point given a 5% default or whatever the case may be. If they figure your "allowance" is $400, and you get paid $150 from your "final check" because you got fired, I'd imagine the max loan would be $250. Odds are after a few months you are already covering 75% of this anyway with the "savings" they are putting away. I'm sure for what they eat they more than make up for in an algorithm that forces them to be in the black on each active account.