3 ms·
I'm about to go swimming, I do so every day. The truth is that lifeguards at pools rarely ever see "drowning" and almost never have to pull people from the wa
by sandworm101 11y ago
I'm about to go swimming, I do so every day. The truth is that lifeguards at pools rarely ever see "drowning" and almost never have to pull people from the water. It's a one-a-year thing. Heart attacks are more common. I know of one pool locally that in 40 years has only seen two deaths, one heart attack and one murder. Drowning isn't an issue.
More people are hurt in the showers than in the pool. And far more on the deck. It's a matter of energy. A fall in a shower hurts, whereas there is no real falling while swimming. And barefoot elderly people on slick tiles are far more likely to injure themselves than the worst swimmers once in the actual water. Poor swimmers rarely get into trouble in modern pools. Instinct protects.
But the article is correct. THIS is what a drowning child really looks like: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/b7/NirvanaNevermindalbumcover.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/b7/NirvanaNeverm...
- RaleyField 11y ago> Drowning isn't an issue. Unless the website isn't showing drownings happening in the same pool 27 times, but hundreds of identically constructed pools then the website is a counterexample showing that drownings happen relatively regularly. Obviously there are numerous factors, but the primary factor that we don't see more deaths is that lifeguards exist.
- Nadya 11y agoSo let's concede that pools as a whole are safe and drowning in a pool happens, at most, maybe once a year. Per public pool. Per city. Per state. So now we have thousands of people drowning each day - many rescued by lifeguards. In the USA, 10 people drown (and die) per day on average. What if more people could recognize when someone was drowning? What if we could bring 10 down to 8? 6? You'd save hundreds of lives each year. All it takes is educating people. Going a bit further, what about the ocean? What about a family swimming in a lake? The issue that is being pointed out is that people drown within feet of another person who could help because drowning doesn't look like drowning. If you pay attention to the videos - a lifeguard saves a child who was drowning while they were surrounded by about 5-6 other kids swimming right next to them who didn't even notice. That's the problem.
- sandworm101 11y ago10 drownings per day, but take away all those involving alcohol, physical accidents (ie hit on head by boat then drown), drownings that happen at night ... and you have a very small number. Kids, or anyone else for that matter, drowning in supervised public pools is almost unheard of statistically. It's akin to being struck by lightning. You are much more likely to die on the drive to the pool than while in it. So greater safety can be gained though countless other measures. One popular in my area is to teach people how to swim through free lessons. That's reduced the number of river drownings significantly in recent years.
- Nadya 11y agoHow many do you take away because a lifeguard was there to save the person from drowning?