4 ms·
But that's the distinction between contractor and employee, right? A contractor "contracts" for work, i.e. they negotiate the terms and prices individually. A
by nostrademons 11y ago
But that's the distinction between contractor and employee, right? A contractor "contracts" for work, i.e. they negotiate the terms and prices individually. An employee is "employed" - their employer tells them what to do and gives them money in return. That's why two of the main tests in contractor-classification lawsuits are "Can the contractor set prices?" and "How much control does the employer have over how the work is done?"
- ahallock 11y agoI don't know, gov rules and regs are unclear and create this type of divisiveness, winners & losers, etc. I would only ask, do the Uber drivers get a choice? What if I value my flexible work schedule over setting my own price. Maybe I'm fine with the price Uber sets and I don't want to worry about it, but I do value being able to work certain hours so I can visit my grandmother at a certain time. If I'm an employee, I don't get the luxury anymore.
- nostrademons 11y agoYou actually do at a wide variety of places - every job I've ever had had no problem letting me duck out in the middle of the day to do errands, visit my grandmother, celebrate my anniversary with my girlfriend, etc. Anyway, this is a pretty interesting case historically, legally, and economically. The reason we have labor laws is because way back in the 1800s, the pendulum swung the other way. Early merchants paid their suppliers by piece-work, and negotiated each shipment individually. During the industrial revolution, corporations found it more economical to dictate exactly how employees performed their jobs, with set hours and assembly-line processes, and gradually this contracting turned to employment, under terrible terms (because workers had no bargaining power for their newly-unskilled jobs). Over time, we got the organized labor movement, which managed to say that "If you're going to dictate how we do our jobs, what's in it for us? You might as well provide us with security and decent wages," which is how we got employee benefits. Every regulation creates a dead-weight loss: that's the share of transactions that would have occurred in a free market, but which don't because either party now finds it too much of a hassle with the regulations. Uber and other sharing economy companies have stepped into the dead-weight loss created by labor laws: they fill the share of transactions that would have occurred if companies in these industries were not required to provide employee benefits. All well and good for Uber & its drivers, and not so good for competitors. The problem comes down the road, where Uber etc. have outcompeted everyone else in the industry, and all the jobs are independent contractor ones with prices set by the app. Then you're pretty much forced to accept whatever bargain they provide - and without legal protections, it probably won't be a good one. So no, Uber drivers don't really get a choice. Hope they're happy with the one Uber provides. (This is all just analysis, and I don't really have a personal position one way or another. I've generally found it a lot more fruitful to work on things lots of people want and not many people can do, because then you have negotiating leverage and can demand flexible hours regardless of what your employer wants. I think that many of the sharing-economy contractors are working against their own long-term interests, but I'm not one of them, so it doesn't personally affect me.)
- ahallock 11y ago> You actually do at a wide variety of places - every job I've ever had had no problem letting me duck out in the middle of the day to do errands, visit my grandmother, celebrate my anniversary with my girlfriend, etc. You've been lucky then. I have that now, but previously, it was pretty rigid. > The problem comes down the road, where Uber etc. have outcompeted everyone else in the industry, and all the jobs are independent contractor ones with prices set by the app. I see what you're saying, and we don't want to repeat history. I just find it hard to believe with the agility of startups and ever-decreasing technological barriers that Uber won't have serious competition in the next few years. Anyway, I appreciate the history of labor law and explanation of dead-weight loss.
- prostoalex 11y agoDon't think that's correct. Lead-generation services like ThumbTack, RedBeacon or any "home warranty" outfits solicit professonals such as electricians and plumbers at their own pre-determined prices, yet at no point an independent electrician is confused with a RedBeacon employee. If someone posts a Craigslist ad asking for two movers with a truck and mentions a specific budget, they're not automatically entered into a W-2 relationship.
- nostrademons 11y agoThe contractors on Thumbtack (at least) set their own prices. I've used them a couple times and they always come back with a range of bids, sometimes differing by up to 2.5x. Ditto Craigslist; you may mention your budget, but the movers will quote you a price, and there may be some negotiating back and forth until you find a price that's mutually acceptable. IIUC, Uber gives drivers a set rate per fare, and it's take-it-or-leave-it. (And no, they're not "automatically entered" into a W-2 relationship - it's not as cut and dried as that. But "ability to set prices" and "ability to control how the work is done" are 2 of ~5 criteria used to determine whether a contractor is really an employee, and they are two of the most important criteria.)
- prostoalex 11y agoSome might counter-quote, but the default behavior is to ignore the listings where the bid seems too low. By the same token an Uber driver can choose to "chase the surge" and only tune in during high-demand time in a high-demand area.
- kefka 11y agoAnd offering only during surge pricing at a set rate is somehow equal to setting out a shingle with your desired price? Right.