5 ms·
> I find it funny that web pages are trying to be native apps and many mobile apps are shipping when they're ostensibly just web pages. Which provides some ins
by tedunangst 11y ago
> I find it funny that web pages are trying to be native apps and many mobile apps are shipping when they're ostensibly just web pages.
Which provides some insight into what's missing from the web. It's almost good enough for most companies. They just need a little something extra so that they can "own the experience." But soon the browsers will catch up and then websites will be able to own your experience, too.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoPerhaps the choice lies outside of the actual functionality of the web itself but instead in the OS and browsers. Consider someone who ships their iOS app that is basically just a web page instead of using a web page. For doing this, they get two benefits that are not really related to the web. One, they get an icon to tab from the home screen to launch their app, instead of going to Safari and then going to their webpage. Two, they get to avoid having to go through Safari, which one could speculate is something Apple was already wanting them to avoid as it allows Apple to create a better walled garden (not to say Apple is the only one who does this, I'm only pointing them out because I used iOS in my example). How would a change/upgrade in web standards allow for the web app to compete with the iOS app housing a web app on these two fronts?
- andars 11y agoJust in case you're not aware, you can already make web apps in iOS have a icon on the home screen. See https://developer.apple.com/library/safari/documentation/AppleApplications/Reference/SafariWebContent/ConfiguringWebApplications/ConfiguringWebApplications.html https://developer.apple.com/library/safari/documentation/App...
- mark_l_watson 11y ago+1 thanks for that! Does anyone have a link for something similar for Android phones?
- Keithamus 11y agohttps://developer.chrome.com/multidevice/android/installtohomescreen https://developer.chrome.com/multidevice/android/installtoho...
- rhaps0dy 11y agoHTM5 appcache to the rescue! http://www.html5rocks.com/en/tutorials/appcache/beginner/ http://www.html5rocks.com/en/tutorials/appcache/beginner/ It's rad.
- Margh 11y agoRad is definitely not my experience. I've spent A LOT of time trying to get my site's appcache functionality to the point where it's barely usable. Probably more time than all of its users would have spent downloading the resources it was supposed to cache. It has more gotchas than anything else I've ever experienced. This is incredibly accurate: http://alistapart.com/article/application-cache-is-a-douchebag http://alistapart.com/article/application-cache-is-a-doucheb...
- benmathes 11y agoFrom a tech standpoint, yes. There are some pretty powerful interests that don't want to see the open web on mobile. Google and Apple get handsome cuts of all the revenue on their semi-closed platforms. Consumer demand may shift that, but I'm not holding my breath. The open web was an historical anomaly: historically the large information infrastructures have been nearly monopolized (telegraph, phone lines, cable/broadcast).
- dasil003 11y agoThe web is an anomaly yes, but it has broader reach than any other platform in the history of mankind. Thinking that native apps will kill the web is to miss the forest for the trees. None of these proprietary platforms have the reach of the web. No computing device maker can release a credible device without web support. It doesn't matter how much money you have, you can't make your proprietary platform cross the chasm the web has crossed. Apple can't do it, even open-source Android can't do it, because Android is runtime, not a standard. The common narrative of PC app -> Web app -> Mobile app is only superficially accurate in terms of where the tech hype was at different points. But in terms of long-term life cycles, mobile apps are much more like PC apps, and the web is something else completely different, which we've never seen before, and mark my words, it will not disappear or be superseded anytime soon.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agothe web is something else completely different, which we've never seen before, and mark my words, it will not disappear or be superseded anytime soon Smalltalk environments? That's the gist of it. The web is a file server protocol with a pseudo-Smalltalk coating. We've seen hypertext systems in general many times before the web.
- dasil003 11y agoNone that crossed the chasm. That's what makes the web special and unique, not the functionality.
- rimantas 11y ago
- nitrogen 11y agoWhat if I don't want corporations to own my experiences? An information-driven web with a document model is robust and can work with many different user agents. An experience-driven web with an application model is very fragile and will only be available to sighted, hearing, Mac-using people running a big 4 browser.
- kbenson 11y agoWho needs flash when we can have 15 competing application frameworks for the web that all just abuse the canvas as their medium, so we aren't even authoring HTML/CSS anymore?
- sanderjd 11y agoHonest question: is abusing canvas really becoming prevalent? The only web app I've seen doing this is flipboard.
- kbenson 11y agoPrevalent? I don't know. I do think it's just a matter of time before some companies leverage this by providing a super simple web page developer tool a la Frontpage Extensions. Photography studio webpage that just wants a carousel and music playing? Check. Small companies that freak out about people stealing their inventory list? Check. Vendor lock in for the poor souls that fall for this? CHECK.
- sanderjd 11y agoHmmm, maybe I'm naive, but I really don't see anything to suggest that things are headed this direction.
- morenoh149 11y agoyeah I don't think that would be crawlable and we want seo
- anon4 11y ago
- marssaxman 11y agoI really don't want them to "own the experience." I want their brochures to stay nicely sandboxed in a browser where they don't invade my computer and try to tell me what I can do with it.
- immibis 11y agoBrochures are documents, nobody has a problem with putting documents on the web. Also, mobile apps are sandboxed already on all major platforms.
- marssaxman 11y agoRight, I meant it as something of an insult. I'm fine with documents on the web. I'm fine with interactive documents on the web. I'm not fine with "web apps" that try to jump out of the browser, opening windows, redefining control-key sequences, breaking bookmarks, "open in new tab", and the back button, and otherwise interfering with my ability to control my own experience on the web.
- dendory 11y agoNo they won't, because it would kill the web. That little bit is ownership: branding and control. There's no Adblock for their app. Their app isn't called Firefox it's Company Name. There's no dev tool for the app, so less chance to find out all the insecure ways it siphons my data. They control updates, so their ActiveX-style monstrosities are always going to be displayed the same. Get the idea?