7 ms·
I have doubts whether Edward Snowden would get a fair open trial, with a jury of his peers. Serious doubts. The entire Snowden affair reminds me very much of D
by mark_l_watson 11y ago
I have doubts whether Edward Snowden would get a fair open trial, with a jury of his peers. Serious doubts.
The entire Snowden affair reminds me very much of Daniel Ellsberg. At the time Ellsberg was condemed by many (especially in the military industrial complex) as a traitor but now I think that just about everyone believes that Ellsberg did a good thing for our country and society.
I think that history will look kindly at Snowden - Lisa Monaco and President Obama will be on the 'wrong side of history' on this issue. I personally believe that we can have an effective intelligence force that acts in accordance with international law and protects our rights of privacy and due process of law. The overreach by those running our intelligence operations smells like a power grab that is not in the best interests of American citizens.
- justin66 11y ago> I have doubts whether Edward Snowden would get a fair open trial, with a jury of his peers. There's not really a lot of doubt. A trial under the Espionage Act is not a fair, open trial.
- mbrock 11y agoWhen John Kerry called Snowden a coward and a traitor, Ellsberg wrote an article for the Guardian, "Snowden would not get a fair trial - and Kerry is wrong" [1], concluding: "John Kerry's challenge to Snowden to return and face trial is either disingenuous or simply ignorant that current prosecutions under the Espionage Act allow no distinction whatever between a patriotic whistleblower and a spy. Either way, nothing excuses Kerry's slanderous and despicable characterizations of a young man who, in my opinion, has done more than anyone in or out of government in this century to demonstrate his patriotism, moral courage and loyalty to the oath of office the three of us swore: to support and defend the Constitution of the United States." [1]: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/30/daniel-ellsberg-snowden-fair-trial-kerry-espionage-act http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/30/daniel-...
- fweespeech 11y agoYeah. Its sad how the political class resorts to disingenuous lies whenever they feel challenged.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y ago>but now I think that just about everyone believes that Ellsberg did a good thing for our country and society. I think there are a lot of "security" hawks that would disagree.
- cgearhart 11y agoIt is my understanding that the Espionage Act does not allow for an affirmative defense -- so Snowden can't claim that he was justified in releasing the materials, rather he can only dispute the facts as presented by the prosecution. But since we all pretty much agree about the facts of the case, the outcome is predictable. It would be "fair and open" in some sense, I guess, but the game is rigged. (Not to say that he is innocent or guilty, just that "come face charges" is basically equivalent to "come serve jail time" in this case.)
- Zikes 11y agoAs I tried to point out below, this is exactly the situation jury nullification was designed for. Guilty under the law, but pardoned by a jury of his peers.
- voxic11 11y agoYeah but the government would never allow someone who would nullify the law to serve on his jury. Just like they removed all jurors who wouldn't consider the death penalty from the Boston bomber trial.
- cgearhart 11y agoEven so, few people know that jury notification is an option (and promoting it is actively discouraged by the legal community), and it would be hard to convince a jury that he was justified because he wouldn't even be allowed to claim or present evidence that it was justified. He would just have to hope that his jury knew about nullification, and that they knew enough about the case beforehand to believe he was justified despite the prosecution presenting evidence that he willingly broke the law. Those are long odds.
- basch 11y agojury nullification isnt designed, it is a byproduct of the system. it is a consequence of the arrangement, not a purposeful inclusion.
- caskance 11y agoThis is exactly the case a pardon is designed for.
- srj 11y agoChelsea Manning was basically driven insane before even getting to trial. Held naked in solitary confinement, in a cell not much bigger than a closet, and forced to stand for most of the day as to not be able to sleep. That prosecutors would stack the jury is almost immaterial - life changing punishment would be inflicted before even getting to that point.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mcv 11y agoThis is worth pointing out. Despite Obama's criticism of Guantanamo Bay (in words only; actions are still lacking), it's important that we remember that Chelsea Manning was tortured on his watch.
- acconrad 11y ago> I think that history will look kindly at Snowden I don't. As much as I want it to, and as much as the HN group wants to, the crazy (sad) thing is that a vast number of Americans not only do not know who he is[1], but those that do are polarized as to whether he did the right thing or not[2] - he barely won a majority vote of the minority who even know who he is. [1] https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/04/06/john-oliver-interview-political-disengagement-american-public/ https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/04/06/john-oliver-in... [2] http://www.newsweek.com/most-americans-think-snowden-did-right-thing-poll-says-253163 http://www.newsweek.com/most-americans-think-snowden-did-rig...
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoFortunately, the average American will not be writing the history of the early 21st century. Just imagine how horrible our understanding of past events would be if that was the case. And there's a number of people we idolize today that were demonized by the government of their time; take Martin Luther King for instance.