3 ms·
A member of the military might not have any problem at all with the "accidental" assassination of their leader, whether that leader is the president or the comp
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
A member of the military might not have any problem at all with the "accidental" assassination of their leader, whether that leader is the president or the company sergeant. AI could easily provide plausible deniability.
I've been very critical of claims of the dangers of AI, but this isn't about AI - this is about giving lethal weapons to autonomous systems.
And that's just stupid. All software has bugs, and even if you don't have a problem with autonomous killing systems - I certainly do - it's incredibly irresponsible to build systems that could kill just because someone left out a semicolon or couldn't convert between miles and km.
It's taking the "blue screen of death" experience just a little too literally.
- bryondowd 11y agoUmm, we already have machines that can kill people if someone "left out a semicolon". Airplane autopilots, medical equipment, car computers, etc. Not saying this makes it OK, but that isn't the reason. Life-critical code isn't a new thing.
- jaawn 11y agoAnd those systems all have humans operating in conjunction with them, none of those things are (currently) autonomous. The success thus far of life-critical code usually depends partially on the assistance of humans.
- bryondowd 11y agoMost of those systems operate on their own unless/until they hit something they can't handle and a human is standing by as failover. So, unless you're saying it's OK to have deathbots as long as a human is on hand as failover if the deathbot gets confused, I think my point stands.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoIMO, the current state of the F-35 rather suggests it doesn't.