4 ms·
The flip side of this is that the boardroom decision will come down to can the billion dollar tax be passed onto the consumer or competitors? If you apply that
by notahacker 11y ago
The flip side of this is that the boardroom decision will come down to can the billion dollar tax be passed onto the consumer or competitors? If you apply that to some other forms of IP like patents, the answer is "quite possibly yes"
The individual creative will relinquish copyright after 20 years, even if they're still hoping somebody might one day make a film out of their work and are kinda keen on having some sort of creative control. On the other hand, Disney will potentially still be shifting enough videos and merchandise to be renewing copyrights up to year 49. It's not exactly unprecedented for major studios to create high value brand families out of 20 year old books either, but in this case they'd rarely need to cut the author in on the profits.
Other than the revenue raising potential, that actually seems worse than the current situation for skewing copyright in favour of the brand families.
- qznc 11y agoI like our german version "Urheberrecht". It is different from copyright because it cannot be transfered. Some comic character cannot be owned by a corporation which milks it for decades and centennials. An author can only give a licence to a company. I always wonder what really happens whenever I transfer copyright for my papers to some publisher. It probably has no effect here in Germany, but is it valid in the US? Then I also wonder if TTIP might change anything about this?
- fluidcruft 11y agoOh, please. That's a distinction without a difference unless you're saying that German authors can't hire legal representation or assistants and must actively negotiate and manage each license solo.
- mason55 11y agoThe distinction is that once the author dies the work falls into the public domain. For as long as they are alive they can license it to a company, and the company can defend it or do whatever, but when the owner dies the copyright dies with them.
- fluidcruft 11y agoI don't see how that can be possible. The Berne Convention established a minimum of 50 years after death and the EU harmonized to 70 years after death.
- hussong 11y agoSome parts can not be transferred, but others can, particularly usage rights (publishing etc.) and licensing happens all the time.