3 ms·
The problem with the "unicorns" in the private market is that its getting funded size wise as if it's a publicly traded company. Ubers 40Billion valuation isn't
by ThomPete 11y ago
The problem with the "unicorns" in the private market is that its getting funded size wise as if it's a publicly traded company. Ubers 40Billion valuation isn't based on it's funding not on it's actual performance (400million revenue, 400million spend).
As long as a private company can getting to the next round of funding it doesn't matter if it's actually even close to becoming a sustainable business. So you can basically keep extending a "false" business in that all you need is convince someone to believe you can become even bigger than you already are, but without showing it through your actual revenue.
As a publicly traded company this wouldn't ever work. Amazon isn't making a profit but it keeps growing revenue wise (for now) if that somehow stops then it will get hit too.
At least thats my take on it.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoPrivate valuations aren't based on current revenues, they're betting on future revenues. In the case of Uber, they're predicted to grow 6x from last year (on target) and 3x in 2016. Another example, when eBay bought PayPal in 2001 future revenues from as far as 2011 (10 years!) were baked into the 1.6bn price. (Which was a _great_ purchase)
- ThomPete 11y agoOh I agree. Of course it's based on betting on future revenues which will work for some and not for others but thats not really the point I am trying to make. What I am saying is that on the current private market you can keep a company with a fundamentally unsound business in suspended animation for a long time and keep enjoying growing valuation as long as you can convince investors that they will be able to raise the next round. I.e. without it actually having proven that's it's a sustainable business. Most of the unicorns happens to be from the valley and as far as I can see have more or less the same investors behind them indicating at least to me that it's not purely based on being better at betting on the right companies. This is a very different feedback-loop than the public market where your ability to make a profit at market expectations often is is king and where this ability is measured every quarter. Maybe I am paranoid but thats what I see. And yes I haven't gotten my head around a proper way to formulate his intuition yet.
- forgetsusername 11y ago"Private valuations aren't based on current revenues, they're betting on future revenues." Private valuations aren't unique in this aspect. All prices are based on expectations of claims on future cash flows.
- cableshaft 11y agoAmazon hasn't made a profit only because they've chosen to re-invest every penny of profit they would make back into the company. If they were forced to show a profit next year, they could pretty easily make a few cuts here and there and produce a profit. http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2014/09/07/the-internal-economics-of-amazons-no-profits-growth-model/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2014/09/07/the-inter...
- ThomPete 11y agoI am aware of why they haven't made a profit. The point is that this is still a bet and if the strategy doesn't hold up they will be punished much more quickly than a privately funded company. My point is that the latency that exist in privately funded unicorns can end up creating a bubble exactly because the feedback loop is too slow.