4 ms·
Interesting from a licensing point of view: the GPL does not require you to redistribute changes that are 'internal' to your organization. You are not redistri
by davidw 11y ago
Interesting from a licensing point of view: the GPL does not require you to redistribute changes that are 'internal' to your organization. You are not redistributing the program itself in this case, you're just letting someone access it.
For some people, this kind of end-run around the GPL is the poster child for the AGPL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affero_General_Public_License https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affero_General_Public_License
- Sanddancer 11y agoThere's a distinct possibility that it's not based on MySQL at all. From their prior discussions, this looks like a clean implementation that just uses its API, so even if MySQL were AGPLed, Amazon wouldn't need to release anything.
- Zikes 11y agoBut thanks to recent rulings [1], APIs are still copyrightable and fall under the same license. [1] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/10/google-oracle-java-api-copyright-battle-lands-at-supreme-court/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/10/google-oracle-jav...
- sneak 11y agoI believe parent is using "API" in the "wire protocol" sense, not the "intra-process programming interface" sense. Those have not been deemed copyrightable as yet, because those don't necessarily require header files.
- mathnode 11y agoIt's just a storage engine, albeit a very good one (I was on the beta); storage engines act as a plugin to the mysql/mariadb server layer, and are typically just a separate binary.
- sneak 11y agoThe AGPL is fundamentally flawed. Imagine if Google were subject to it; the idea of free software is to have the option to modify that which you run yourself. Without a million spindles, Google's main products are useless to you. Services are different than software.
- xyzzyz 11y ago> Imagine if Google were subject to it; the idea of free software is to have the option to modify that which you run yourself. Without a million spindles, Google's main products are useless to you. Without years of expertise, and tons of free time, you will not be able to modify the free software either. You can have someone do it on your behalf though, and just as well you could have had someone (Yahoo? Microsoft?) run Google software for you, had it been available as free software.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Without years of expertise, and tons of free time, you will not be able to modify the free software either. You can have someone do it on your behalf though, and just as well you could have had someone (Yahoo? Microsoft?) run Google software for you, had it been available as free software. I'd like to see something like this with regards to B corporations or non-profits. Something like Gmail, Gravatar, or the like that are services you can pay for, but they're not run for-profit. Companies can bid on the management of the service, maintenance of the underlying open source packages, and so forth. Something between municipal fiber and Wikipedia, but for SaaS services.
- jbandela1 11y agoCan't you get around the AGPL by just making it an internal service on your network? Basically it looks like this. Internet --> Your API service --> AGPL program Your API service uses the AGPL to implement it's logic. Since the FSF holds that API cannot be copyrighted, Your API service implements the same API as the AGPL program and uses a network connection to the AGPL program running on another computer to implement the API. Since the Internet user never connects to the AGPL program, they are not entitled to the source code. You are required to release the source code to the users interacting with the AGPL program over the network. You therefore release the source code to the implementers of Your API service and call it a day. Adding another layer of indirection solves a lot of problems in computer science, even GPL and AGPL
- brianwawok 11y agoHas this been tested in court? Clever engineering solutions seem not to always win the day in front of a Judge.
- bhouston 11y agoThere is no mention of Internet, just a network server. You scenario is likely covered by the license.
- ahachete 11y agoThat is correct. However, only if there is effectively the API service in the middle, making your AGPL program internal. But if you are exposing an AGPL program (let's say a database) as-a-service, you cannot have an API service in between (unless you'd re-implement all the API yourself) and hence exposing directly the AGPL database, in which case you are bound by the license with respect to the users.
- codebeaker 11y agoThanks for posting this, we've had some arguments with our investors and their lawyers recently about (specifically Golang, in our case) GPL and AGPL meanings and how they relate to SaaS. One case in point we have a cronspec parser package licensed AGPL (what the hell!?) which doesn't even include a web server or listener code of any kind… so are we in violation by using it to parse cronspecs that our customers have entered into our SaaS API?!) Do you have any citation, references, or case-law I could use as a starting point to steal your arguments as my own?
- rjsamson 11y agoSo the way Werner Vogels explained it at the AWS Summit in NYC recently, Aurora is built from scratch and is MySQL compatible, but it is not a fork. He mentioned that they broke it down into components which are each built on pre-existing AWS services - for example, the storage layer just DynamoDB which I thought was really interesting.
- juliangregorian 11y agoI would love to hear more about this, if you know where I can find more info.
- rjsamson 11y agoHere's the point in the keynote where he starts talking about it - really interesting stuff! https://youtu.be/0rPpCnFE-hU?t=33m34s https://youtu.be/0rPpCnFE-hU?t=33m34s
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]