3 ms·
As long as you have something you can't control (some closed blob) it will only increase security risks. That's not a solution at all. And baseband in common ha
by shmerl 11y ago
As long as you have something you can't control (some closed blob) it will only increase security risks. That's not a solution at all. And baseband in common handsets is a horrible abomination.
- derefr 11y ago"Closed" and "out of your control" aren't identical. You could have, for example, an OS that ships the source to its baseband firmware as part of it, where the baseband firmware has a deterministic build process that produces an object SHA-identical to the signed blob, assuming the signature is out-of-band. With such a setup, you wouldn't be able to replace the firmware yourself on a production device... but you'd be able to modify the firmware source, submit a pull request, and determine that your change made it into the next version of the blob by doing the deterministic build yourself. Basically exactly the same idea as verifiable release binaries for things like Tor.
- shmerl 11y agoIn practice, currently you have neither control, nor the source for it. On the contrary, as was already published about mobile devices, baseband has access to the main system memory (which is a spooky thing).