3 ms·
Yes, I'm glad that you can use templates to re-implement operator new [] in a way that is susceptible to integer multiplication overflows. In all seriousness t
by asveikau 11y ago
Yes, I'm glad that you can use templates to re-implement operator new [] in a way that is susceptible to integer multiplication overflows.
In all seriousness though, I really mean it when I say I intellectually understand the C++ fan's response to a number of these issues. It took me a long time of writing C but I do understand the template-nerd habitat, and can acknowledge its strengths and use those tricks when working in a .cpp file. What frustrates me is to see the rigidity with which it is followed, and the failure to understand the world in a different way. There is a different world out there that doesn't mind an implicit conversion from void pointers, and they're not "wrong".
- sjolsen 11y agoMy point isn't about templates or memory allocation (hence the code that doesn't check for overflow or worry about object construction). It's that implicit casts from void* are unnecessary in C++, addressing your complaint that it's annoying not to have them. My point is that the lack of implicit casts from void* should not be frustrating, because there are in what are by far the most common use cases equally convenient ways of doing the job. >What frustrates me is to see the rigidity with which it is followed, and the failure to understand the world in a different way. There is a different world out there that doesn't mind an implicit conversion from void pointers, and they're not "wrong". I have seen and lived in the world where casts from void* are common, and where making those casts implicit is a convenience (and that world is not the world of C++). I understand that world. I understand that viewpoint. I just strongly disagree with it.
- asveikau 11y ago> It's that implicit casts from void* are unnecessary in C++ Very well aware of the C++-head's answer to these problems. > My point is that the lack of implicit casts from void* should not be frustrating, This was a discussion about whether or not C++ is a superset of C. I wrote up the difference that frustrates me the most and all other comments were missing.