2 ms·
By the time you've said "Why is it so terrible to be punished for exercising your right" I would hope the answer would already be apparent. Being punished for e
by mikeash 11y ago
By the time you've said "Why is it so terrible to be punished for exercising your right" I would hope the answer would already be apparent. Being punished for exercising your rights is the opposite of having those rights.
- shasta 11y agoI realize that phrasing is getting me down voted. If I'd phrased it as "Why is it so terrible to be rewarded for not exercising your right", I probably wouldn't be getting down voted. But really, what's the difference?
- mikeash 11y agoIndeed, what is the difference? It's just phrasing. So if you can see why it's bad to be punished for exercising your rights, surely you can see why it's bad to be rewarded not to.
- shasta 11y agoI think I've been fairly clear that I find both acceptable. Thinking in terms of "rights" instead of costs and outcomes just increases the chances of a bad decision.
- mikeash 11y agoWould it be accurate then to say that you don't believe people should have the right to a fair trial?
- shasta 11y agoYou couldn't possibly have thought this was going to be a helpful comment to anyone when you posted it.
- mikeash 11y agoHow so? From what you've said, not only does that seem to be what you think, but you seem to have no trouble with the idea. Am I wrong?
- shasta 11y agoSee my sister post. My apologize if you honestly thought that was a useful post. I would certainly not characterize my position as not being in favor of fair trials. But phrasing it terms of rights I do find unhelpful. Doesn't an innocent person have a right not to be jailed? But what's the point of even phrasing it that way?
- mikeash 11y agoThe point of phrasing things in terms of rights is to set goals for ourselves. We believe that innocent people have the right not to be jailed. Sometimes they are anyway. But not jailing innocent people is one of our goals. Similarly, people don't always get a fair trial, but when we say that we believe people have the right to a fair trial, that means that our goal is for every accused person to have one if they want it. So, here is my reasoning: you say that you think it's a good idea to punish people for getting a fair trial. If you punish people for something, then it's inherently not a right, because if it's a right then the goal is for everyone to have one if they want it. Thus, you think that people should not have the right to a fair trial. Note that I asked for clarification rather than just stating that this was your position, because I wasn't sure. So your upset response does not make sense to me. Further, I don't understand why you find that phrasing to be distasteful, since you seem to be against the notion of phrasing things in terms of "rights" anyway. If you think "rights" are not a useful concept here, why is it wrong to say that you don't believe people should have the right to a fair trial?
- shasta 11y agoI don't think that "rights" is the best framework for evaluating alternative systems. I still understand what you mean when you use the word, though, and obviously I do think the accused should receive fair trials.