3 ms·
There's a lot of "the DA says", and "the prosecutor says", and "the DA argues". And on the opposite side is a myriad of proceedings, of which the bank was exon
by FireBeyond 11y ago
There's a lot of "the DA says", and "the prosecutor says", and "the DA argues".
And on the opposite side is a myriad of proceedings, of which the bank was exonerated, on every. single. charge.
- rayiner 11y agoThe Bloomberg article relies a lot on quotes from the DA, but many of the underlying facts do not seem seriously disputed. For example: > The Abacus clients whose aborted closing sparked Ken Yu’s termination lost their deposit on the property when the loan fell through. They went to the police and filed a complaint, mentioning that Yu had falsified their mortgage application. The police referred the matter to the DA. > its loans wouldn’t have met Fannie Mae’s income requirements, and the bank depended on Fannie’s money for a significant chunk of its profit. > In April 2011, Yu pled guilty to grand larceny, fraud, and falsifying business records, and is cooperating with the investigation > The accused employees include Yiu Wah Wong, the bank’s chief credit officer, who reported directly to Jill Sung; and Wai Hung “Raymond” Tam, the loan origination supervisor, who trained the bank’s loan officers and processors The NYT article in contrast spins this whole utterly irrelevant narrative about an immigrant-founded bank. Note also that there are two separable questions: 1) why was the bank prosecuted; 2) was the bank guilty. The two questions are related, but distinct. The NYT article is about (1) not (2). What's relevant to (1) is what facts and testimony the prosecutor has available when he decides to prosecute. There was plenty of facts and testimony to justify this prosecution. If this were HSBC instead of a small bank people on HN would be furious if the prosecutor didn't go after the bank with the kind of evidence he had. The fact that the prosecution ultimately lost does not mean, as the article suggests, that the prosecutor was wrong to bring the case in the first place. If prosecutors could predict what evidence juries would credit at the end of the day, there would be no need for trials.
- lostcolony 11y agoFrom everything I see in the Bloomberg article, there would have been a lot of reason to prosecute Yu, but not the bank, as as soon as they saw anything suspicious they acted on it. But what did the prosecutor do instead? He gave Yu a plea deal to try and indict the bank. Which went no where. Also from the Bloomberg piece - "But in the wake of the financial crisis only one bank in the whole country has, as an institution, been criminally indicted for mortgage fraud: Abacus." And that bank was exonerated on every charge. So what it -looks- like, is a DA's office that wanted to get a high profile case, leaped at the chance to try and pin something on a bank (a small one, that won't have the legal counsel that a large one would have, and won't risk making real enemies), despite having very little to go on, and they couldn't make anything stick. Or, sure, it could be that this little bitty bank was into some shady stuff but was so good that even though their plan to play nice with the DA early on by turning over info didn't work, they were still able to recover and convince a jury of their innocence. I'm really inclined toward the former though.
- elektromekatron 11y agoThe article doesn't suggest that the prosecutor was wrong to bring the case because they lost, but rather because the case they presented was farcical.
- hga 11y agoThe Abacus clients whose aborted closing sparked Ken Yu’s termination lost their deposit on the property when the loan fell through. They went to the police and filed a complaint, mentioning that Yu had falsified their mortgage application. The police referred the matter to the DA. Besides the unfortunate but I suppose inevitable detail that the applicants lost their deposit to the property owner, nothing new or unacknowledged by the bank. its loans wouldn’t have met Fannie Mae’s income requirements, and the bank depended on Fannie’s money for a significant chunk of its profit The jury, AKA the finders of fact, disagreed with the allegation at the beginning of that snippet, the latter is just gilding the ragweed. ADDED: as FireBeyond notes, ~30K/year isn't much profit. Per this http://www.ibanknet.com/scripts/callreports/getbank.aspx?ibnid=usa_762773 http://www.ibanknet.com/scripts/callreports/getbank.aspx?ibn... its most current annual net income is 430,000, but that's certainly weighed down by the 10 million the NYT article reports they had to spend defending themselves. So ~30K/year is, as our intuition suspects, minuscule, certainly not "a significant chunk of its profit". In April 2011, Yu pled guilty to grand larceny, fraud, and falsifying business records, and is cooperating with the investigation Entirely congruent with the claimed actions and position of the bank, and mentioned in less detail in the NYT article. The accused employees include Yiu Wah Wong, the bank’s chief credit officer, who reported directly to Jill Sung; and Wai Hung “Raymond” Tam, the loan origination supervisor, who trained the bank’s loan officers and processors Well, yeah, and mentioned to some degree in the NYT article, but, again, the finders of fact disagreed with the prosecutor's allegations.
- FireBeyond 11y ago"> The Abacus clients whose aborted closing sparked Ken Yu’s termination lost their deposit on the property when the loan fell through. They went to the police and filed a complaint, mentioning that Yu had falsified their mortgage application. The police referred the matter to the DA." See, this is one of those facts that is more disputed than you seem to describe. Sung noticed discrepancies, multiple checks to be written out, which were incongruous with common practice, called Yu to explain what was going on. She then noticed him outside the branch talking animatedly to the borrowers, and realized something wasn't right, and stopped the finalization of the loan. "She begun investigating, and found trails of several fraudulent loans. By the following Monday, Yu was fired." So less than a week from the incident to his dismissal. Yet to listen to the DA, the bank only acted after the prosecutors began asking questions. Do you see the Manhattan Police and DA turning that (a fraud complaint) around into a criminal investigation into a bank in four business days or less? Or is the bank's story, that yes, this was happening, was discovered and the employee "immediately" terminated (because even for a small bank that's still a quick turn around in investigating financial fraud and falsified business records) actually accurate? "> its loans wouldn’t have met Fannie Mae’s income requirements, and the bank depended on Fannie’s money for a significant chunk of its profit." Yet the article states that the bank only received $120K in servicing fees across all Fannie Mae loans in several years. I'm not sure even a small bank sees $30K/year divided amongst however many mortgages (only a small fraction of which were determined to be fraudulent) as a "significant chunk of profit". "If this were HSBC instead of a small bank people on HN would be furious if the prosecutor didn't go after the bank with the kind of evidence he had." Perhaps if HSBC did as this bank did and fire all employees found to be in on this, rather than awarding them bonuses and promotions, people would be a lot less furious?