5 ms·
This is absurd. The results of raising the minimum wage are perfectly known. Learn from the other countries that have done it in the last 10-15-25 years. Austra
by grecy 11y ago
This is absurd. The results of raising the minimum wage are perfectly known. Learn from the other countries that have done it in the last 10-15-25 years. Australia, Scandinavian countries, etc. etc.
Why can't America look outside it's own borders and learn from what other countries have done and are doing?
i.e. watch this John Oliver video on gun control [1] where it's stated Australia is not on this planet and America can't learn anything from what they've done, because Australia is not the real world. Why do people think this way?
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9pOiOhxujsE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9pOiOhxujsE
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- replicatorblog 11y agoIs your contention that there's no difference in raising wages in small countries with largely centralized populations vs. a country of 320M with massive regional differences? Sweden and New York City are roughly the same size. California is quite a bit larger than Australia, so we will soon see how these experiments compare in real life.
- BurningFrog 11y agoThe size of the country does not matter for microeconomic effects.
- JonFish85 11y agoChanging a wage for a country, as the post said, is probably a bit more macro- than micro-
- BurningFrog 11y agoThe standard Microeconomics¹ analysis is clear: If an employee is paid $10/h and produces $12/h of value for the employer, the employer makes a profit of $2/h and will want to keep the employee. If they must pay $15/h this becomes a $3/h loss, and the employee will be fired. It's hard to see where the size of the country would enter into this. Of course, if a raised minimum wage causes higher unemployment etc, this will have macro economic effects, but that's secondary effects. ¹ A more descriptive name for this branch of Economics would be "Price Theory", but we're stuck with the name.
- replicatorblog 11y agoFactor in culture. People of Scandinavian descent do even better financially in the US than they do in their home countries. Even if true in a textbook sense, I'd bet the sense of social cohesion that comes from a small culture has an outsize impact on that country's economic output. But lets watch the experiment play out. Maybe the book stores in SF that are closing due to the new wage are just abberations or unfortunate side effects.
- paulhauggis 11y agoAll of the countries you list have huge costs of living. I went to Australia last year and a coke and a small bag of chips at 7-11 was ~$12. Instead of raising minimum wage (which is a short-term bandaid, because inflation will eventually catch up), we should be focusing on educating those that can only get a minimum wage job.
- jon-wood 11y agoWho does the minimum wage jobs once that happens? Those people coming after also deserve a decent wage.
- moistgorilla 11y agoYou are wrong. The world isn't as simplistic as you suggest. Just because something works in Australia or in some Scandinavian countries doesn't mean it would work in the US.
- ovulator 11y agoDid you read the article? You can't compare the effect of economic change in two vastly different countries like that. As the article stated, even within the United States, within the state of New York, the policy would have vastly different effects between cities such as New York City and Buffalo.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Why can't America look outside it's own borders and learn from what other countries have done and are doing? The doomsaying about minimum wage increases occurs every time this is discussed in the US, and the doom fails to materialize every time. This isn't an issue about the people doing to doomsaying not learning from what other countries are doing; they are ignoring the US as much as any other country. Its true that, if you assume no impact on spending behavior (and, therefore, on demand), minimum wage increases will be expected, in net, to make certain jobs that are currently net benefits to employers into net losses, resulting in them being eliminated, without any compensating effects. OTOH, the contention of those that support any particular minimum wage increase is that, in the range actually proposed, the increased pay to those whose jobs remain net benefits to their employers will increase demand in sectors which drive employment less than the reduced retained employer profits will decrease demand, such that demand will be increased enough in fields with sufficient impact on employment that the benefit provided by employees working will increase enough that, while their may be shifts in the sectors of employment, net employment will not decrease. And the facts of historical minimum wage increases have never shown the fears sold by the doomsayers being realized.
- dang 11y agoPlease don't bring generic ideological tangents into already-controversial topics. Any vector that runs through the points "minimum wage studies", "American self-centeredness", and "gun control" is guaranteed not to lead to substantive discussion. The OP may be wrong, but it's hardly absurd. Let's stick to the substance.
- deciplex 11y agoHow can you stick to the substance if drawing on other examples is out of bounds?