3 ms·
I don't quite see the logic here. What does the medial professional gain from letting you die to try save someone else? If there is nothing to gain (no financi
by dspillett 11y ago
I don't quite see the logic here. What does the medial professional gain from letting you die to try save someone else?
If there is nothing to gain (no financial reward, or reputational bonus, or so on) or there is but they have the appropriate morals to turn it down, then they aren't going to risk the nagging of their own conscience and/or looking bad by letting you die.
If there is something to gain (and they are mentally capable of letting themselves take advantage of that) then it is going to happen whether you are a registered donor or not. If they can convincingly let you die without recompense they can hide your organs in the paperwork so it doesn't look like a non-donor organ has intentionally been used.
So whether or not you are screwed in a situation where this discussion is relevant is not at all determined by whether or not you are registered as a donor. By choosing not to donate you are not controlling any such situation in the way you hope you are.
There is the grey area where, for example, you have a 20% chance of survival but with the transplant someone else has a 60% chance - then things get a but more tricky depending on your paranoia level, though IMO the chance of that is rather small (the chance of getting hit by a bus on your way home from work or shot by some loon in a movie theatre is so much higher that it doesn't make sense to be committing time to thinking about this) and to be honest I'd probably not mind all that much if it did happen... Then again some might discount my opinions here because many don't seem to understand my reasoning in the following point of view: If I were in a permanent vegetative state or riddled with dementia or similar I'd gladly shuffle and donate my organs to help several others (who still have a chance of some desirable quality of life) on the way out. The only thing stopping me registering as "FFS just let me go when I get close to that sort of state, because I'm no longer me and there is no point throwing time and money at keeping the husk that is no longer me going" is that there is no legal way of doing so.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>I don't quite see the logic here. What does the medial professional gain from letting you die to try save someone else? Cost benefit analysis to save the most people. "He is already pretty much dead. We could keep trying and maybe damage the organs, or go ahead and call time of death and get these organs to save 3 other people." For me, the bigger issue is that of the 'beating heart donor' where your organs are harvested while you are brain dead but your body is still alive. I don't trust our understanding of brain death enough to say that pain isn't felt (consider the rare cases of people who are anesthetized enough they appear unconscious to the instrumentation but are able to recall parts of the operation including sometimes feeling pain).
- LordKano 11y agoI don't quite see the logic here. What does the medial professional gain from letting you die to try save someone else? Prestige and money. When a millionaire is dying of heart failure, do you think s/he goes to whichever doctor has an opening on the schedule or do you think that s/he will seek out the doctor who has the best record for saving people in his/her position? There is the grey area where, for example, you have a 20% chance of survival but with the transplant someone else has a 60% chance There's nothing grey about it. Unless the donor explicitly authorized the removal of the organs before the onset of clinical death it's unethical. I don't care if it's 1% versus 99.99%, my organs are mine.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIts an old philosophy problem. Expand it - a healthy person walks into a hospital (to change the water bottles on the water cooler). They are kidnapped and taken into a back room, and their organs are 'parted out' to save 10 people. A definite Win! for society, right? In a utilitarian sense.
- walterbell 11y agoOnly if people are fungible. What if the healthy person was about to invent __ that would improve __ survival rates?
- msandford 11y ago> I don't care if it's 1% versus 99.99%, my organs are mine. Morally, yes. Legally, no. You can't sell your organs because you don't own them. You don't own yourself because who knows why? It's the government's way of solving a variety of problems regarding people who aren't exactly in their right mind. Sadly it has some other unfortunate outcomes as well, like you can't legally take your own life no matter how much you're suffering.
- LordKano 11y agoYou can't sell your organs because you don't own them. That's not entirely accurate. I can give them away, because I do own them. I could give someone one of my kidneys. I could give someone a lobe of my liver. I can and one day may give someone some of my bone marrow. I can and have given away some of my blood.