17 ms·
Raising Floor for Minimum Wage Pushes Economy into the Unknown
- civilframe 11y agoI don't believe that raising the minimum wage will trigger businesses to cut jobs significantly. They will probably pass the higher cost onto the consumer. Ultimately, it's a method of wealth redistribution, which is sorely needed in our economy.
- johnjac 11y agoThe problem with this type of wealth redistribution is that the poor are often consumers of the same products and services served by min wage jobs. This is one of many reasons I support unconditional basic income. It allows labor to be accurately priced in the market, without raising cost to the poor.
- thomasfoster96 11y agoI'd agree, but raising the minimum wage is a relatively good alternative to doing nothin given unconditional basic income is merely a political dream in most jurisdictions. The US has such a low minimum wage given the wealth within the economy it's hard to see a rise having much of an impact.
- w1ntermute 11y agoAn EITC would more effectively incentivize the poor to work than unconditional basic income.
- dllthomas 11y agoAssuming it doesn't taper, yes.
- ashark 11y ago1) An EITC fails to realize the efficiencies of consolidating or eliminating other forms of aid that basic income could. 2) The incentive to work under basic income is having more than barely enough money to scrape by. Wages will go up until this is a sufficient incentive. My money's on wages not having to rise much at all, if any, to achieve this. I wouldn't even be surprised if average compensation dropped a bit under basic income. 3) An EITC doesn't support entrepreneurship and small businesses the way basic income could.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> An EITC would more effectively incentivize the poor to work than unconditional basic income. Maybe, but: (1) This is an assertion provided without evidence, and (2) The purpose of the basic income isn't to incentivize poor people to work, anyway, and (3) Poor people, even before considering EITC or Basic Income, have more than sufficient incentive to work, what they generally lack is opportunity to work with their current skill set, and opportunity to gain the skills needed to work where it is in demand without trading off present necessities.
- thomasfoster96 11y agoI should've clarified: by impact I mean negative impact on business costs and employment rates.
- fweespeech 11y ago> The problem with this type of wealth redistribution is that the poor are often consumers of the same products and services served by min wage jobs. This is one of many reasons I support unconditional basic income. It allows labor to be accurately priced in the market, without raising cost to the poor. Yes but labor is less than half of the cost for everything. One of the most labor intensive is food [growing -> market -> consumer] and its still not even 50%. https://www.fmi.org/docs/facts-figures/marketingcosts.pdf?sfvrsn=2 https://www.fmi.org/docs/facts-figures/marketingcosts.pdf?sf... http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/307995/aer780d_1_.pdf http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/307995/aer780d_1_.pdf Its 38.5%. The impacts is similar on other areas where the minimum wage laborer is also the minimum wage consumer. The pay increase still flows ~60% to the people on minimum wage and is the most effective method that is politically feasible. [e.g. Backed by a large portion of a major political party] Ideally, raising the standard deduction to the poverty level for 1 person as well would be ideal to spread things out more. Of course, you'd need to raise the marginal tax rates [e.g. Money after $11,700/year would be taxed at a higher rate] to do that since it'll cost hundreds of billions otherwise :p [e.g. $6,300 -> $11,700] http://familiesusa.org/product/federal-poverty-guidelines http://familiesusa.org/product/federal-poverty-guidelines
- afarrell 11y agoYou would also want to have the IRS automatically fill out the tax returns of people making less than 3x the poverty line. Otherwise the poor and frazzled would not take advantage of this.
- jefurii 11y ago> this type of wealth redistribution As opposed to the kind where the bosses pay absurdly low wages and distribute the profits to themselves? Update: grammar, typo
- icebraining 11y agoNo, clearly as opposed to UBI. Did you read the whole post?
- Kequc 11y agoAs a general rule prices in a capitalist society are already as high as they can be. Any higher and they would be undercut. When a company becomes large and therefore able to produce goods for less money, the price doesn't fall, profit margins increase. These large businesses are the ones paying employees the federal minimum wage. Only thing that happens is their profit margin shrinks a tiny amount. As long as the profit margin is in the black the business will continue to operate. It puts more money into the pockets of consumers, who are the drivers of the economy.
- JonFish85 11y ago"As a general rule prices in a capitalist society are already as high as they can be." What you're discounting is that once the minimum wage is raised, the market can bear higher prices, and will move accordingly.
- ealexhudson 11y agoIt's not a huge number of people on minimum wage that would be affected by an uplift: in the UK in 2014, there were around 1.5M minimum wage jobs, 50% of which in hospitality, cleaning and retail (so, many not full time). The average wage shift would be virtually imperceptible and the extra spending power of those on the minimum wage does not translate to measurably higher prices (in the UK the minimum wage has rarely followed average earnings, and it's difficult-almost-impossible to measure the spending of minimum wage earners separately).
- davis_m 11y agoIt isn't just the people on minimum wage that would get a raise. Anyone making between the current minimum wage and the new minimum wage would receive a pay bump. I don't have the numbers, but I would guess that there are more people within a dollar or so of the current minimum wage than there are actually at the minimum wage. The trend in the US is for people to at least get nominal raises that would technically raise them above minimum wage, but well below the proposed new minimum wage.
- 11y ago
- rhino369 11y agoPassing costs on the client isn't something you can just do. Many products and services have elastic demand. Fast food, for example, has been has found it very hard to raise away from their dollar menu pricing. Businesses don't have to cut jobs either. They just have to move them. Edit2: Costumers can also shift to lower cost alternatives. Online retailers have less overhead and lower labor costs. If you make Walmart more expensive than Amazon, Walmart will shutter stores laying massive numbers of people off. Edit: Some economists have argued that past raises in min wage have not made noticeable impacts in employment. But this is way outsides of a normal rise in minimum wage. Going to 9 or 10 makes a lot sense. 15 dollars will put people in most of the country out of work.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago>15 dollars will put people in most of the country out of work. So be it. Can't find a job that offers a living wage? We provide a social safety net and increase taxes on the wealthy to pay for it. Make more than a million dollars a year? 95% marginal tax rate. Tax rates are the lowest they've been in the history of the US, and all we've seen is a disgusting level of income equality.
- JonFish85 11y ago"Make more than a million dollars a year? 95% marginal tax rate." Great. Then what? Everyone currently making over $1m a year will cut their salary to $1m. Then you gotta start taxing the upper middle class -- what rate do you want to tax people making over $500k? $250k? $100k? Those are the ones that will pay for this program. As much as you want to tax "the wealthy", there really aren't enough wealthy people to pay for everything, and it comes down to how much you want to tax the moderately successful person who is trying to pay for their 2 kids' college expenses while saving to have a retirement.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Great. Then what? Everyone currently making over $1m a year will cut their salary to $1m. Do wealthy individuals in other countries with a heavier tax burden (Europe, Scandinavia to be specific) do this? Would be nice to see evidence of this behavior before outright dismissing raising taxes.
- phaus 11y agoIts a form of wealth distribution that's going to have the largest negative impact on the lower and middle class. I agree we need to do something to solve the problem of poverty in this country, but this doesn't seem like it would redistribute wealth from the middle class to the poor, not the rich to the poor.
- BurningFrog 11y agoThen why not raise it to $100/h, so everyone can live a comfortable life?
- littletimmy 11y agoReasonable person: 8 glasses of water keep you healthy. You: WHY DON'T YOU DRINK 100 LITERS A DAY IF YOU LIKE IT SO MUCH!!
- BurningFrog 11y agoWell, yeah, I'm interested in what mechanism people think will make going to $100/h or $30/h fail, and what makes it not apply for $15/h.
- unprepare 11y agoI'll take a crack at this. Because 100$ per hour is not what labor is currently worth. The whole idea behind making the minimum wage a livable wage is to stop allowing corporations to keep wages artificially low by having workers augment their wages with government provided subsidies. So what people are saying is, when you account for the subsidies people currently being paid minimum wage are taking advantage of, the real cost of that labor is much closer to 15$ per hour than the current 7.50$ per hour. Shifting the minimum wage to 15$ an hour will shift many people with minimum wage jobs off of government subsidy programs, actualizing the real cost of labor on corporations and lowering the burden of our current government programs. so this is much more than just picking a number and saying 'wages should be at least this high", its more "youre are paying X, we are subsidizing that by Y, we think you should pay all of X+Y"
- bko 11y agoBusinesses would generally charge the price that would result in the most profit (revenue - expenses). Businesses can't just raise prices and get more revenue. If they could, they would do that already. Minimum wage has to do with marginal cost of producing an extra product. Marginal cost generally increases after a while. So producing that last additional unit usually costs more than the one before. When you increase cost in the form of the price of human capital, the marginal cost of producing a unit will increase and the intersection with the marginal revenue (price of the unit) will drop to a lower quantity supplied and higher price. So yes, prices will go up but the business will also sell less units. Since less units are sold, there will be less capital that will need to be utilized. Prices aren't arbitrarily set and increase in price will result in less units being sold and less employment. This isn't as controversial as journalists make it out to be. Pre-political Paul Krugman does a great job explaining it: > So what are the effects of increasing minimum wages? Any Econ 101 student can tell you the answer: The higher wage reduces the quantity of labor demanded, and hence leads to unemployment. This theoretical prediction has, however, been hard to confirm with actual data. Indeed, much-cited studies by two well-regarded labor economists, David Card and Alan Krueger, find that where there have been more or less controlled experiments, for example when New Jersey raised minimum wages but Pennsylvania did not, the effects of the increase on employment have been negligible or even positive. Exactly what to make of this result is a source of great dispute. Card and Krueger offered some complex theoretical rationales, but most of their colleagues are unconvinced; the centrist view is probably that minimum wages “do,” in fact, reduce employment, but that the effects are small and swamped by other forces. > What is remarkable, however, is how this rather iffy result has been seized upon by some liberals as a rationale for making large minimum wage increases a core component of the liberal agenda–for arguing that living wages “can play an important role in reversing the 25-year decline in wages experienced by most working people in America” (as this book’s back cover has it). Clearly these advocates very much want to believe that the price of labor–unlike that of gasoline, or Manhattan apartments–can be set based on considerations of justice, not supply and demand, without unpleasant side effects.[0] [0] http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2015/03/02/paul-krugmans-amazing-about-face-on-the-minimum-wage/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2015/03/02/paul-krug...
- seanflyon 11y ago
- Turing_Machine 11y agoIt isn't super-rich people who shop at Walmart, eat at McDonalds, or patronize most other low-wage businesses, so I don't think your "wealth distribution" theory is correct.
- civilframe 11y agoCheck page seven of http://www.bls.gov/opub/reports/cps/characteristics-of-minimum-wage-workers-2014.pdf http://www.bls.gov/opub/reports/cps/characteristics-of-minim... for some insightful statistics.
- Terr_ 11y agoIMO one of the interesting ways to think about: "Overall, how does our economy value human-time versus material-goods"? Even if the cost is passed on to the consumer (many of whom will, in turn, will have more to spend) it represents a shift in how we (implicitly, through costs) balance "1x Acme Appliance" versus "1x hr child care", etc.
- mring33621 11y agoLandlords will benefit, short term. I suspect that people will move to areas offering higher minimum wages, which will drive up rental housing costs in those areas.
- maxerickson 11y agoI think in some places the people making the new higher minimum will already be priced out of the housing market for the area the job is in. That doesn't rule out housing price increases at the other ends of their commutes, but I wonder if it will diffuse it quite a bit.
- grecy 11y agoThis is absurd. The results of raising the minimum wage are perfectly known. Learn from the other countries that have done it in the last 10-15-25 years. Australia, Scandinavian countries, etc. etc. Why can't America look outside it's own borders and learn from what other countries have done and are doing? i.e. watch this John Oliver video on gun control [1] where it's stated Australia is not on this planet and America can't learn anything from what they've done, because Australia is not the real world. Why do people think this way? [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9pOiOhxujsE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9pOiOhxujsE
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- replicatorblog 11y agoIs your contention that there's no difference in raising wages in small countries with largely centralized populations vs. a country of 320M with massive regional differences? Sweden and New York City are roughly the same size. California is quite a bit larger than Australia, so we will soon see how these experiments compare in real life.
- BurningFrog 11y agoThe size of the country does not matter for microeconomic effects.
- JonFish85 11y agoChanging a wage for a country, as the post said, is probably a bit more macro- than micro-
- BurningFrog 11y agoThe standard Microeconomics¹ analysis is clear: If an employee is paid $10/h and produces $12/h of value for the employer, the employer makes a profit of $2/h and will want to keep the employee. If they must pay $15/h this becomes a $3/h loss, and the employee will be fired. It's hard to see where the size of the country would enter into this. Of course, if a raised minimum wage causes higher unemployment etc, this will have macro economic effects, but that's secondary effects. ¹ A more descriptive name for this branch of Economics would be "Price Theory", but we're stuck with the name.
- SilasX 11y agoWhat's the difference between "raising the minimum wage" and "raising the floor for the minimum wage"? Is that just a redundant headline?
- Someone1234 11y agoI think the minimum wage is a helpful tool or has been historically. But as others have said when you raise the minimum wage, prices increase, and by far the largest groups that consume the same goods/services are also relatively poor themselves (so essentially you increase pay but also costs to the poorest in society). More as a thought experiment than anything: What would happen if, instead of increasing the minimum wage, we capped the MAXIMUM wage at companies to 500x the lowest? That would effectively cap the CEO's pay at 6.9 million dollars for ANY business which pays the national minimum wage. That might sound like a lot but a lot of CEOs at larger corporations are getting in the order of 20 million right now (and this would have almost zero impact on small-medium businesses, as their CEOs don't make enough yet). I guess what I am asking is: Instead of increasing minimum wage, what would happen if we could align the interests of the poorest employee and richest employee in a business? PS - I am well aware that CEOs often don't take direct pay and instead take other financial instruments, such as stock. Instead of getting sidetracked into all of the potential workarounds, can we discuss the moral/legal/practical of tying the lowest/highest employee pay together?
- rmah 11y ago"when you raise the minimum wage, prices increase" You state that as if it's a fact when it is not. Prices may increase for some goods/services. But many goods/services prices are not set by the costs involved but by what the market will bear. The other option is that profit margins will narrow. Or, as is more typical, a combination of both.
- JonFish85 11y ago"by what the market will bear. The other option is that profit margins will narrow" You say this back-to-back, but seem to completely ignore the fact that the market can bear a higher cost once the minimum wage is raised. Sure, $15/hr won't affect the price of Porsches or Lexuses, but the lower-priced goods that someone making minimum wage is buying will likely be affected.
- JonFish85 11y agoSerious question (not flippant): what good does that do? Wal-Mart's CEO makes $35m (I think). They employ 2.1m people. He makes $16.66 per person that he manages (indirectly, of course), per year. His salary is a drop in the bucket of what it costs to employ their workforce for a year. Comparing salaries doesn't showcase anything. How many of these high-paying CEO jobs are there? Not many! The same is true of sports--there are only so many jobs to go around, and if you're one of the rare people who can do the job, you get paid a LOT of money. Comparing salaries of highest and lowest paid people doesn't really seem useful in any way.
- bko 11y ago> Their evidence rests largely on comparisons between neighboring areas with different minimum wages. The seminal study in this vein examined fast-food restaurants on both sides of the Pennsylvania-New Jersey border before and after New Jersey raised its minimum wage in the early 1990s. It found no evidence that employment there fell as a result. This is often cited in publications that generally support a higher minimum wage. It is unfortunate that this is never challenged as there are studies that show that an increase in minimum wage does in fact result in lower employment: > Raising the minimum wage would increase family income for many low-wage workers, moving some of them out of poverty. But some jobs for low-wage workers would probably be eliminated and the income of those workers would fall substantially. [0] Logic itself would suggest that an increase in minimum wage would result in at least some unemployment: No employer would hire you if you make them less than the amount that they have to pay you. There are people that make more than the old minimum wage and less than the new proposed minimum wage. Therefore, those employment opportunities will no longer exist. It may not happen overnight as there is some momentum, but you can't deny this effect. Also, you can't exactly measure the people that would have been hired with a lower minimum wage. The other interesting this is how vernacular plays such a strong role in people's opinions. Imagine if "minimum wage" was replaced with "prohibition of employees whose contributions to employers is less than the mandated minimum amount of finding legal employment" [0] https://www.cbo.gov/publication/44995 https://www.cbo.gov/publication/44995
- erikpukinskis 11y agoYour assertion may or may not be true, but there's no way I am willing to accept that as "logic". Your assumption is that the profit margin on labor is 0% which logic would suggest is pretty universally false. Here's my logic, maybe you can help me find the flaws in it: businesses are trying to maximize sales and minimize costs, which means they have the smallest possible workforce required to support their current sales. Less staff means less sales. They are also making some profit. As long as the wage increases are less than their profit margin, they have no reason to fire anyone. They lose revenue if they fire anyone, or they would've already done it. So to me he relevant question is: what is the ratio between profit and minimum wages at most companies? I looked at Wal-Mart as an example and they make way more in profit than they spend on wages.
- crazy_geek 11y agoI find it interesting that when the government distorts a market via pricing controls, taxes, or other means, the law of unintended consequences almost inevitably kicks in and it's result is either "bad luck" or calls to "fill in the loopholes!" Distort the market and people are rational-enough agents and will change their behavior, just not necessarily entirely in the way you hope/want. There is no free lunch. Either the economic distortion makes it cost-effective to pay people to find ways to dodge the distortion and come up with strange, but legal, means to avoid it, or there are shortages, or the price of things go up. It's like trying to squish one part of a water balloon -- the other part of the balloon will deform in some way. Some examples: "The Double Irish arrangement" for tax avoidance, ObamaCare effectively limiting part timers to 30 (or 35, I forget which) hours/week, or strict zoning laws causing property values to skyrocket due to lack of supply of housing in SF.
- kuni-toko-tachi 11y agoIt is foolish to think that this won't result in unemployment. We live in a time in which higher labor costs for marginal work can be eliminated through automation and these higher labor costs will only accelerate that transition. You may not like that fact, but that's what will happen. You don't a free ride on planet earth and no foolish government policy can change that.
- deciplex 11y agoIndeed. Minimum wage is a hack on labor that barely worked 60 years ago when full employment was some sort of reasonable goal. It's a ludicrous superstition now - better to just institute a basic income, abolish minimum wage entirely, and let employers pay people whatever they want.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoThe real minimum wage is always 0.