3 ms·
> Next lets talk about lying, which is making a statement you know to be false. Now buy a PowerBall lottery ticket, hand it to your special friend and tell them
by shkkmo 11y ago
> Next lets talk about lying, which is making a statement you know to be false. Now buy a PowerBall lottery ticket, hand it to your special friend and tell them "This Lottery ticket is a winner." are you lying?
Yes. You can say 'I believe/think this lottery ticket is a winner' or 'This lottery ticket could be a winner' and those are not lies. However the statement you discuss is a statement of a fact that you know is extremely unlikely to be true and is thus a lie.
You can make statements of fact about things that you are reasonably certain are true and will generally not be called a liar. However you will be being more honest if you qualify that statement of fact by as to the amount of certainty you have.
The point of this article is that deliberately expressing a level of certainty that you know doesn't match the actual certainty is lying. There are ways to express confidence without expressing certainty.
> Nobody accuses the quarterback of lying when he tells the wide receiver he is going to through the pass to him, only to be sacked behind his own line of scrimmage.
Due to the context people know that "I will throw the pass to you" is intended to mean "I will try to throw the pass to you.". The same thing does not generally apply to interpreting "This lottery ticket is a winner" (a lie) to mean "This lottery ticket could be a winner" (not a lie).
- ChuckMcM 11y agoFair enough, although I think you are trying to have your cake and eat it too. And as an engineer I share your desire to have people make precise statements. But they don't. When I tell you that the lottery ticket I'm giving you is a winner, you probably understand that it is only a winner if the numbers are drawn at the correct time. You might ask, has the draw already occurred? (knowing that to be the critical feature) and I would either say "Yes" and you would know that I was literally accurate in my statement, and if I said "No" you would know that I was probabilistically accurate in my statement. You would then act in your own self interest based on your understanding. So if I'm a founder and tell you that the company I'm trying to hire you to come work for is going to be a huge success. You might ask "What are your current success metrics?" or "How much revenue do you have?" And based on those answers you could tell if I were speaking literally or probabilistically. The "interesting" (from the philosophy point of view) is the statement "This lottery ticket is a loser" is just as much as accurate as "This lottery ticket is a winner" because the operation is binary. For every startup (or company) I've ever been in, or recruited people to come work for, I've been very clear about what is the upside and what is the downside. And generally people understand that. And I have heard people (and people have pitched me) with outrageous "sure bet" sort of things. Which I have politely, and respectfully, picked apart at the places where I have concerns. The most recent was last week when I listened to a pitch for a new product idea to connect people and jobs. I idea is really clever, if you have a critical mass of people who are looking for jobs and people with jobs participating. But there is a huge gap between the world of today, and the world where all those people are participating. If that person wanted me to believe that there was any chance it was going to be a huge success, I would have to believe they could get a critical number of people on board. They don't yet have a way to do that, so I don't yet believe they will be successful. They are completely honest and forthright about the potential success, once they have critical mass, so I don't consider them to be lying to me when they say it will be a huge success. I just know that they don't yet know how they are going to get there. The original article was a sort of 'wake up sheeple' sort of call to action but I felt that was completely unwarranted. Sure there are some new folks who, in their first job, might feel like the possibility to suddenly be a billionaire is just around the corner. Just at one point they may have believed that all college courses are trivial. But experience teaches us to think, and when we think about startups we have to think critically about the likelyhood of various scenarios coming true or not.
- normloman 11y agoBut we're not talking about founders lying about their start-ups chances (the lottery ticket is a winner). We're talking about founders lying about the present situation of their start-ups (not being transparent about financial health of the company). If, like you say, both parties involved understand the risk, why can't founders disclose more?
- ChuckMcM 11y ago> why can't founders disclose more? I expect it revolves around how people treat information. Have you heard the paradox about if you found out that in the future you would be able to time travel, and so in the present you slack off on an exam knowing you can come back and fix it later, but slacking off results in you not discovering time travel? There is a similar one in leadership where if you, as a leader, express doubts about the future your team will have doubts about the future and then they won't be operate at the level they need to in order to succeed. In some cases folks will believe that if they share all the information it will spook their team and make the negative outcome even more likely. Of course you can't know that until you actually try it, and once you try it you can't reverse it. Not surprisingly, one of my personal stress 'nightmares' (dreams I get when I'm under a lot of stress) is that I've just done the one thing that, having done it, it is now clear it is going to make for a worse outcome. I don't doubt there are times when extra transparency would be a positive, and where it would be a negative. And I understand why people, unable to predict if it would help or hurt, choose not to be more transparent.