4 ms·
> What exactly makes Eisner a "sociopath" and Brin & Page "normal decent people"? Because Google proclaimed that they will "do no evil". So therefore they are
by rdtsc 17y ago
> What exactly makes Eisner a "sociopath" and Brin & Page "normal decent people"?
Because Google proclaimed that they will "do no evil". So therefore they are not evil ... fire up your blogs praising Google in 1...2....
Of course a few dissidents who were turned in by Google to face long prison sentences in countries with oppressive regimes might have something to say about the track record of the "do no evil" policy, but somehow everyone already forgot about that.
Once a company outgrows its founders, becomes a publically-traded behemoth, it is really not that different from other publically-traded behemoths. Some just learn from the mistakes of others, and handle their marketing and PR better (e.g. Microsoft is considered the "Evil Empire" so we will market ourselves as "good" on the moral spectrum).
For instance, it helped Google's PR tremendously to take a "moral stand" as a company. Perhaps their cost-analysis showed that when they do something immoral nobody will notice and they'll use their awesome marketing skill, and everyone will forgive and forget. It worked great in that respect. But that typifies sociopathic behavior.
Now I am not blaming Google too much. I think it is the legal environment that creates a Darwinian competition where sociopaths rise to the top. If companies had personalities (I don't think they do, at least not to the extent that everyone anthropomorphizing them), most would be diagnosed as dysfunctional sociopaths. Those that aren't, we never hear about.
- pyre 17y ago> Of course a few dissidents who were turned in by Google to face long prison sentences in countries with oppressive regimes might have something to say about the track record of the "do no evil" policy, but somehow everyone already forgot about that. No offense, but saying that they were 'turned in' is a little loaded. The governments queried Google for identities and got them. I never heard of a story where Google was actively searching for dissidents to turn into the government like some sort of bounty hunter.
- rdtsc 17y agoNo offense but "queried" them is a little loaded as well. Can't imagine these dissidents displayed their, name and address in the open. So "queried" is more like, "turning in the IP address and the time-stamp" at the request of the Chinese government. And I don't really buy the "we have no idea why the Chinese govt. would want these" possible excuse from Google. Never-mind their active participation in blocking information and issues relating to Tibet and thus contributing to the problem. Well, I expected to get down-voted on HN for even alluding that Google would do something wrong, and for not worshiping Sergey & Larry. This is definetly Google fanboy country. "Hail Almighty Google!" -- there, fixed it now. Let the points roll in.
- pyre 17y agoMy only point was that there is a difference between "responded when prompted" and "actively sought out information to exchange." I'm definitely no Google fanboy. It just really irks me when I see something that is seemingly trying to convince me of a point with subtle cues rather than just presenting the information. I have no problem 'attacking' people that share values with me if I think that they might be misrepresenting the facts or just coming across in a way that would hurt 'the cause.'