3 ms·
Yes, open source software is unique and special. But that's another reason it doesn't fit neatly as a 'textbook' example of a public good. The classical excluda
by gojomo 17y ago
Yes, open source software is unique and special. But that's another reason it doesn't fit neatly as a 'textbook' example of a public good. The classical excludable/rivalrous analysis didn't even consider things that could be non-excludable by choice, or which might improve qualitatively by being non-excludable.
That novelty cuts both ways. That an open source software producer can't capture the full value by charging a fee would tend to lead to underproduction. But costless communication, redistribution, and sharing-back means they get value in many other ways -- reputation, code improvements, increased sales of excludable complement products, etc.
This is again why the analysis has to be more sophisticated than "if free riders are a problem, then taxpayers should fund".
The Nobel winner was Elinor Ostrum. MarginalRevolution had a high-level summary:
http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2009/10/elinor-ostrom-and-the-wellgoverned-commons.html http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2009/10...
"Qualified economists could determine the budget"? With this and your comment about "a few government sanctioned pg's" I see that you put a lot more trust in disinterested experts and bureaucrats to hand out large sums of money than I do. That process -- boards of politically-favored individuals handing out money -- does not converge on the optimal level of funding/production. We know that with as much certainty as we know there can be problems with private underprovision of classical public goods.
But really, what is the "problem" for which an "imperfect solution" is better than nothing? Open source is booming. People love to create it even for nonmonetary reasons -- so perhaps we already have an inefficient surplus. (Maybe hobbyist open source work should be taxed!)
Meanwhile, governments are having a hard time managing their traditional public goods duties and tax flows in an efficient, sustainable manner. You want to give them a new portfolio of economic responsibilities?