3 ms·
Demoting someone in Google is a virtual death sentence, and yet not only has Google ever been accused of using this vast power, the idea itself is almost unimag
by gojomo 17y ago
Demoting someone in Google is a virtual death sentence, and yet not only has Google ever been accused of using this vast power, the idea itself is almost unimaginable.
A total ban of an obvious competitor would clearly raise so much controversy that it is "almost unimaginable", I agree.
But Google's smaller-scale bans and reorderings, always for ostensibly legitimate purposes, have sometimes caused accusations about Google's real goals by the webmasters affected. That's not to say their paranoia is correct -- but "[n]ever been accused" and "unimaginable" is a bit strong given the real history.
And they are 'demoting' other content incrementally all the time -- whenever they promote their own content in the first few vertical positions. Tried any health-related search on Google recently? As of a couple months ago, 'Google Health', with an image, is almost always the top hit.
Do non-YouTube videos get as prominent placement as YouTube videos?
- SwellJoe 17y agoI've never once seen a website owner complaining about Google that wasn't operating an obvious (to me) spam, or otherwise nefarious, site of some sort. I've even seen a few HN users commenting on such Google evils, and when I looked at the "innocent" site they were talking about, it was inarguably blog spam, content spam, used black hat SEO techniques, or some other nasty type of thing that provided no or negative value for users, and was carefully engineered to maximize ad or referral revenue at the expense of all else. I'm sure somewhere, sometime, some actually innocent website has moved downward in the search rankings, but I've never once seen a complaint about it that was legitimate (it's probably just lost in the noise of all the black hats that complain loudest, since I've never looked for innocent site owners with stories to tell...I just come upon the assholes who scream loudest).
- tptacek 17y agoPatrick McKenzie complains about Google here with some regularity, and it's not all just about customer service (lack of transparency another one).