5 ms·
I had not heard before how much nationalist myths (recently very influential in politics in India) had influenced entries in English-language publications such
by tokenadult 17y ago
I had not heard before how much nationalist myths (recently very influential in politics in India) had influenced entries in English-language publications such as Wikipedia. Suffice it to say that there is utterly no manuscript or epigraphic evidence for what you have said in your comment. The method of history is to work from written records. (Archeology wouldn't support what you said either.) But thanks for letting me know, by pointing to examples, that currently quick Google searches for facts on the history of India are even less reliable than searches for facts on the history of China.
After edit: remember, as the thread is structured, you were the first to claim that peoples more ancient than those of ancient Greece "already knew that physical exercise leads to good health." That was your statement. You linked to pages that people can Google up, but you haven't yet pointed to any primary source for that proposition of undisputed date and provenance. On the one hand, I can accept as a general proposition that human beings for as long as Homo sapiens has been around had an intuition based on anecdotal experience that keeping moving preserves health (and helps catch tasty animals to eat), but on the other hand the epidemiologist mentioned in the article opening this thread really did discover a NEW, more detailed, epidemiological observation, which has been confirmed through multiple channels through physiological experiments in both animal and human subjects.
- miles 17y agoMy dear fellow, if you insist upon maintaining such a patronizing attitude, at least be good enough to provide some documented evidence, even something that can be "Googled up". So far you've offered nothing but blanket statements of supposed fact, hand waving, and sarcasm.