3 ms·
Reduce the number of graduate programme places so the over supply is less, either by reducing the number of places reasonably evenly across the system or by clo
by barry-cotter 11y ago
Reduce the number of graduate programme places so the over supply is less, either by reducing the number of places reasonably evenly across the system or by closing marginal doctoral programmes altogether. There are a lot of universities that graduate Ph.D.s who have virtually no chance of a decent academic position. The first tier universities graduate more than 5 times as many Drs. each year than are necessary to replace their own staff, some much more than that. You need to be an extremely strong second tier graduate to have a chance of getting a position at the same level, never mind going up. Third tier or below are basically exploited for teaching and research labour and then gradually eased out of the system. People should not enter these programmes expecting to get an academic job. Those who enter those programmes would be better off getting a J.D., which is damning. A J.D. is a horrible idea for most people but at least it only wastes 3 years and less than $200K. Most people who enter a Ph.D. programme drop out, in most disciplines, and some people who do graduate take up to ten years.
- FLengyel 11y agoThis is correct. In retrospect my math Ph.D. was a waste of time. There have been proposals over the years on how to address the overabundance of PhDs. One approach seems to have been widely and independently adopted: advise those responsible for easing out the exploited to read Erving Goffman's On Cooling the Mark Out: Some aspects of adaptation to Failure [1, 2]. 1. http://www.tau.ac.il/~algazi/mat/Goffman--Cooling.htm http://www.tau.ac.il/~algazi/mat/Goffman--Cooling.htm 2. http://kieranhealy.org/blog/archives/2002/10/31/cooling-the-mark-out/ http://kieranhealy.org/blog/archives/2002/10/31/cooling-the-...
- sjg007 11y agoThere are thousands of foreigners will to take the places. You can't talk about academia and ignore immigration.
- sjg007 11y agoThere are thousands of foreigners will to take the places. You can't talk about academia and ignore immigration.