3 ms·
While the author has a great underlying point, I find this style of writing a particular disservice: "Perhaps 5% of the population has enough abstract reasoning
by YokoZar 11y ago
While the author has a great underlying point, I find this style of writing a particular disservice: "Perhaps 5% of the population has enough abstract reasoning skill to verbally understand that the above heuristics would be useful once these heuristics are pointed out."
This is a version of "you, enlightened reader, are the special chosen few" - to me it reads no different in rationalist essays as when it gets pitched to me by multi-level marketers selling their get rich quick schemes. If you're familiar with reading bullshit such an appeal to the reader's vanity should immediately send up a few red flags, and it can completely detract from what would otherwise be a reasonable piece.
- jere 11y agoThe site has always given me that vibe. I'm not sure I understand the point of a bunch of people getting together to celebrate how smart they are. Especially since they're pulling statistics out of thin air and using unconvincing examples: you're telling me most comedians don't keep track of which jokes are getting laughs?! My final impression: https://xkcd.com/874/ https://xkcd.com/874/