7 ms·
Right, I'm not saying that "200 OK" means you definitely haven't exceeded authorization, just that it can't reliably be analogized to the physical world.
by nitrogen 11y ago
Right, I'm not saying that "200 OK" means you definitely haven't exceeded authorization, just that it can't reliably be analogized to the physical world.
- tptacek 11y agoBut Rayiner's point is that it's equally ambiguous in the real world. A shopkeeper opens their shop to the public. Nobody has to use a key or flash a card to get in. But you can certainly exceed your welcome in a real-world store, and the law manages to handle that situation, too.
- nitrogen 11y agoThe fact that the law handles the physical world doesn't mean that real world analogies lead to meaningful conclusions about the digital world. That is the point I intend to convey, that the analogies themselves are counterproductive to the goal of producing coherent digital law.
- dimino 11y agoI attended a talk given by Michael Hayden that touched on this concept a bit, with regards to the difference in RoE in "meatspace" vs cyberspace. An example he gave was seeing a cop drive by your house. Ostensibly that'll put you at ease, the concept that a law enforcement agency is patrolling your neighborhood. Maybe the officer gives a wave, or even chats with you for a bit if you're out washing your car or mowing the lawn. You feel safe. How would this possibly translate to "cyberspace"? What if the local PD did a regular port scan of your router, or attempted to crack wifis while on their patrol? We allow searches of our belongings when we get on planes, but when our packets go overseas, we very much dislike the idea that someone from the government might be taking a look. The rules, he went on to say, are simply different, because expectations are different.
- MichaelCrawford 11y agoExpectations may be different but that does not imply the laws are different. Expectations are what engineers have; laws are what Congress passes. I understand that in the State of California it is unlawful to shoot a whale while riding a camel.
- dimino 11y agoActually, it does imply the laws are different, considering the folks who wrote the laws at the time were not considering their cyber implications, and the folks interpreting the laws in courts (judges) themselves have a different set of expectations and understanding when it comes to cyberspace.
- rayiner 11y agoOn the flip side, real world principles don't become irrelevant just because we're talking about the digital world. What does it mean to have private property? It means having the right to exclude. I don't think there is anything difficult about translating that principle to the Internet. What I think happens a lot is that people use "the Internet is different" as a sort of short-hand for the idea that the Internet should be governed by different underlying principles. But I think it's disingenuous to say that the nature of the Internet dictates that it be governed by different principles. The existing property principles translate just fine.
- nitrogen 11y agoThe existing property principles translate just fine. If they did, we wouldn't be having this conversation. As others have pointed out, physical concepts of scarcity and mutual exclusion are nearly meaningless in the digital realm. Digital systems are capable of acting autonomously as agents; they are not just passive property. Measures to ensure technical exclusion bear no useful resemblance to physical security. Computers give the ability to lay out in machine-readable terms what is "public" and what is not. Note that I'm not arguing against the right to decide who can access a computer system and for what purposes, only against the use of analogies to physical spaces and existing laws.
- SilasX 11y agoBut the (purported) violations happen when the trespasser has already left the property. You would need to find a precedent for an "open to the public" property's owner's right to restrict visitors from (off property) telling others what merchant-tenants were offering, under what terms, on that property.