4 ms·
About [1]: "Second, contrary to the implication from the first Times story, Clinton’s emails sent in her role as secretary of state were automatically saved in
by pessimizer 11y ago
About [1]:
"Second, contrary to the implication from the first Times story, Clinton’s emails sent in her role as secretary of state were automatically saved into a secure data system under the control of the department. In fact, where does the Times think the FOIA offices for the State Department and the intelligence community are finding the 55,000 emails now under review that it cites in its new story? Are officials breaking into Clinton’s house in the middle of the night to examine them by flashlight? Nope. They are pulling them off of the system under the department’s control."
The 55,000 emails were exported from the system by her staff, IIRC. I've never read another story that said that her emails were ever under the control of the State Department, which would of course make the email story completely insensible. If this is a false claim, Newsweek is just as confused as the NYT about Clinton's emails, if not more.
At some point the NYT and other media outlets decided the Clinton email story was about "classified emails" rather than an official conducting state business over their own private email. Newsweek is reducing it in this article to an insignificant technicality about FOIA. It's not about FOIA, it's about having a record of state business. FOIA is the only tool that the public has to force release of such records, but FOIA is not the reason we keep them. That's like saying that the reason you have a lock is so you have a place to use the key.
By making the story about the possible release of classified information, it just gives Clinton something that is easy to deny. I wouldn't be surprised if the Clinton team were intentionally steering the coverage in that direction, because when her denials of emailing classified information are proved true, the story will evaporate.