4 ms·
Chisel is a nice toolkit that proved itself in the Rocket processor. One of the more unusual uses of it was Chisel-Q for quantum computing: http://www.cs.berke
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Chisel is a nice toolkit that proved itself in the Rocket processor. One of the more unusual uses of it was Chisel-Q for quantum computing:
http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~kubitron/papers/qarc/pdf/Chisel-q.pdf http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~kubitron/papers/qarc/pdf/Chisel-...
Chisel is pretty well-known in academic, hardware community. So, here's a few that you might have not heard of.
Caisson - language-based security meets HDL
http://www.cs.ucsb.edu/~chong/papers/109-Caisson-pldi.pdf http://www.cs.ucsb.edu/~chong/papers/109-Caisson-pldi.pdf
SHard - a scheme to hardware compiler
http://scheme2006.cs.uchicago.edu/05-saint-mleux.pdf http://scheme2006.cs.uchicago.edu/05-saint-mleux.pdf
Cx-Lang - A statically-typed, c-like, HLL for hardware
http://cx-lang.org/ http://cx-lang.org/
Note: I'd love for some people familiar with ASIC or FPGA design to check out Cx-Lang to see if it's good for beginners getting results on FPGA's. The I.P. they sell is so cheap that it's either (a) crap or (b) the result of a productive, synthesis tool (Cx). Just like to know if it's a decent HLS tool compared to FPGA or EDA company offerings. Additional advantage that it's open so it can be reviewed for subversion if one is willing to invest the effort.
- gluggymug 11y agoJust took at look at the cx-lang website. I think it may be too weird for a beginner looking for results. I've been in ASIC & FPGA engineering for 15+ years. The design flow I think they use is more like writing a program that gets translated into hardware. Very different from the regular methodology. Sounds great but there's a big leap between that and getting your FPGA working. For a beginner, it's too much to take on. I think maybe Chisel and those others would be easier.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYeah, I was actually hoping it was a high-level synthesis tool. I appreciate your review on the ease-of-use aspect.
- gluggymug 11y agoI think it is a high level synthesis tool like a SystemC etc. My concern for a beginner would be how to get your high level design integrated into the FPGA. For a beginner, there are a lot of what-ifs that they are probably going to stumble on.
- trsohmers 11y agoChisel is not high level synthesis, which is one of the reasons why I love it. You are actually describing the circuit itself, with is what a hardware description language is supposed to do. While describing the function of a circuit like MyHDL and many other languages have tried to do it cute, they have never come close to a real engineer thinking of how to solve the problem with registers and combinational logic directly.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoOf course it's not. That's why real HW types use it and people like me don't. ;) One of my goals on HW security side is to bring synthesis to a level that non-HW people can use it for an OK solution. I found Cx when looking at the awesome Qflow method and tools. Since you post a lot, what's your opinion on Cx as a HLS tool for programmers without expertise as HW engineers? And outside big EDA, what is your recommendation for lowest cost vs effectiveness HLS for those wanting to clean-slate their hardware or at least accelerate things on FPGA's?
- gluggymug 11y agoWhile describing the function of a circuit like MyHDL and many other languages have tried to do it cute, they have never come close to a real engineer I agree with you on that. For a beginner I think a high level language is the wrong direction to go because it's taking them further away from the method of designing a HW solution. It's adding another layer of abstraction.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's what people said about going to 3GL's. I'm glad, for my day-to-day computing, that most went in the other direction (pro 3GL's). Software people can't get the kind of results hardware people can while using HLS techniques. That's obvious. Yet, the existing research shows they should be able to get quite a bit of results with little knowledge of hardware. EDA tools actually solved most of the hard parts. Only thing that's lacking are tools to accomplish this and at prices most people can afford. Two paths developed in parallel. One for those trying to boost their software with hardware generation. One for hardware designers trying to improve their own craft. And with the benefit that one's tools can integrate the other. Best of both worlds. So, I look for both.