3 ms·
For tipped workers I thought minimum wage (at the time of the article) ranged from $4.90 to $5.65 in New York. The original Times author (if i remember right)
by cma 11y ago
For tipped workers I thought minimum wage (at the time of the article) ranged from $4.90 to $5.65 in New York. The original Times author (if i remember right) claimed rampant tip-withholding, but you are claiming the ad itself demonstrates wage theft, and it doesn't mention tip withholding.
The author points out the part about illegals, and claimed that at key parts where it talked about workers as a whole, it drew from a sample of only unlicensed workers, which likely includes a larger proportion of illegals. He said the Times should have tried to estimate the size of this pool amongst the total work force.
- Retric 11y agoTips may count as part of pay, but they can't lower net hourly wages below minimum wages when including tips. As the quoted rates are minimum after tips the salon that's already factored into the calculation to reach 70$/Day. PS: If you actually look at the picture you see two customers receiving work (back rub and nails) from multiple workers at the same time. Which means tips are going to be shared and likely to make up some of that 70$ minimum. Sure on a good day tip shares likely bump things past 70$ but per day each worker must always end up over 7.25 including tips.
- cma 11y agoThe ad specifically calls it base pay and says "plus tips and comissions". QUEENS AREA NAILS Seeking several large and small work experienced hands. Base pay $120 plus tips and commissions. Small work $70, plus tips and commissions. Seeking part-time small and large work on weekends. 15 minutes two-way transport Flushing to Elmhurst provided. Responding to your edit: $70/8hr is already $8.75/hr, you did the math wrong.
- Retric 11y agoYes. Have you actually worked a job with tips and commissions? Some days they really end up at ZERO net tips over minimum wage. PS: If the actual calculation where 70$ + f(X) instead of 70$ or f(X) the top opened would likely be far higher as random tips have a lot of a variation. With many waiters receiving at least one 100$ and a few 50$ tips over a few years. I know plenty of waiters that broke 250$ on a good night. But you see the same thing with raft guides, masuse, or bell hops.
- cma 11y agoAs I already pointed out, you did the math wrong, 70/8=8.75, not 8.25. Now you are just trying to resort to whether or not I can personally relate through shared experience, instead of whether your numbers add up. I have worked in an untipped restaurant position near minimum wage but I didn't have to live on it at the time and so can't directly relate to anyone living on minimum wage or below (which doesn't include the people targeted in the ad since they would make above).
- Retric 11y agoUntipped as in you always got a flat rate near minimum wage? That seems like a really bad deal. As to the base pay argument, I have seen a lot of versions of this in sales, but almost always it's base pay of X or a commission structure with many people actually making the base pay for a while and then either being fired or moving on. For the sake of argument we assuming the actual hours worked is only 8 and tips are frequent that might support 100$ as a minimum instead of average day. On the other hand if the average is 100$ and some days hit 150$ then you need several days @70$ to balanced out to 100$. I accept both readings are reasonable based on wording, but even then 100$ per day in NYC at best supports minimum wage in the rest of the US.