3 ms·
Which is another way of saying, maybe the book is not in Medieval Italian. You can't write 35k words in a language, jumble the letters, and have it come out w
by idlewords 17y ago
Which is another way of saying, maybe the book is not in Medieval Italian. You can't write 35k words in a language, jumble the letters, and have it come out with such aberrant statistical properties.
Citing Wikipedia:
"the Voynich manuscript's "language" is quite unlike European languages in several aspects. Firstly, there are practically no words comprising more than ten glyphs, yet there are also few one- or two-letter words. The distribution of letters within words is also rather peculiar: some characters only occur at the beginning of a word, some only at the end, and some always in the middle section."
The link pvg pasted mentions other difficulties.
- knieveltech 17y agoOne wonders if the then-common use of ligatures, abbreviation and short form substitution could account for the apparent discrepancy with the character counts?
- sp332 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gadsby:_Champion_of_Youth#Lipogrammatic_quality http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gadsby:_Champion_of_Youth#Lipog... If you're intending to be obfuscatory, you might come up with "aberrant statistical properties".
- pvg 17y agoNot over any significant length of text and it's not going to be tremendously aberrant. The text of Gadsby is easy to google, try tossing a chapter or two into a letter frequency counter. The resulting histogram still looks a great deal like what you'd get for plain English.