3 ms·
> Only thirty-nine per cent of non-interest-bearing checking accounts were free in 2011, Thanks. So 39% of the types of checking accounts investigated were act
by alkonaut 11y ago
> Only thirty-nine per cent of non-interest-bearing checking accounts were free in 2011,
Thanks.
So 39% of the types of checking accounts investigated were actually free.
If there is no bank that offers a $0/year account with a $0/year debit mastercard attached to it, then something is seriously wrong with the competition in the US consumer banking market.
The article goes on a lot about payday loans, check cashing and so on, and mentions "fees" but doesn't really specify what those fees are, but checks and the fees and problems with them seem to be at the root of the problem.
Couldn't Joe from the Bronx who works at McDonalds just get his $15/h straight to his no-fee account every month? Then buy his gas and toilet paper with his $0/year mastercard? This is how I (and likely much the rest of the world) has done it for many years now.
- 9872 11y agoThere is plenty of competition on that side. The bigger problems are that these people are uneducated and don't trust banks. They also frequently get part or all of their income in ways that dissuade from from putting it in banks because they do not want to pay taxes on it or have to explain what illegal things they did to earn it.
- juliangregorian 11y agoThe bank is not a public good. Think about how they keep the lights on: they reinvest the capital of their clients. If their clients are bringing them hundreds of thousands of dollars each the economics can work; less so for the client with hundreds of dollars. The bank doesn't really want these clients, they can't make money off their capital, so they hit them with fees whenever they can. All "no fee" accounts that I know of have requirements that must be met -- usually a minimum balance, plus (or alternatively) some various combination of others specific to the account. In my experience, the most reasonable of these accounts require you to have at least $100 in your account for the entire monthly period -- if you dip below at any time, you get charged $12 for the month. And then to boot, if you didn't have $12, they might also hit you with a $34 overdraft fee. To much of "the rest" of the world, this is unacceptable.
- alkonaut 11y agoThe cost of just creating and maintaining an empty an account (a record in a database) is about zero, and the debit card company (MasterCard) doesn't really have any costs associated with a card until it's used, at which point there is a transaction fee anyway! It still seems to me that banks should be really eager to just soak up these "unbanked" customers, even if just a small fraction of them ever turn out to generate income in the future. (Say 1/100 inherits some money and starts saving, and 1/100 buy a house with a mortgage. That should easily pay for the 98 people with perpetually empty accounts). Maybe there are some regulations that create per-customer overhead costs in the US? For example, if it's required that banks send out annual statements on paper to their customers, that would be a per-customer cost.
- juliangregorian 11y agoAn account isn't at all just a record in a database. There are tons of marginal costs involved. It seems to me like you should start a banking startup for these customers and get a lesson in how the real world works. Your math alone is laughable.
- alkonaut 11y agoWell, where I live (also in the real world) there are many banks that are happy to provide no-fee accounts without any strings attached such as minimum balance). So the math can't be that laughable. Can you give me an example of the marginal costs of a customer opening an account? The only way we can have so many banks offering these services for free must be that they have very small marginal costs and/or the average expected future profit from these customers is higher than the marginal costs. Conversely, the only reason this isn't the situation in the U.S. must be higher marginal costs and/or lower expected future profits. So, if that reasoning is sound, my question is: what drives the marginal cost up in the US (regulation? low demand for online-only banking e.g due to check use?), or, if that is the case, what drives the expected profit down? Low social mobility? (I.e too low percentage of customers expected to have large savings or mortgages within N years in the same bank)