3 ms·
Cross-fit and its boxes is doing a lot of damage to the reputation of traditional bar bell training by emphasizing weight and reps over form and technique. Man
by sschueller 11y ago
Cross-fit and its boxes is doing a lot of damage to the reputation of traditional bar bell training by emphasizing weight and reps over form and technique.
Many people are getting insured and have long term damage because of poor form and techniques taught by Cross-fit. Even if this is done by box owners it is up to cross-fit to manage their brand and not certify coaches that aren't ready.
If you want to get in shape, spend the time an learn the proper techniques. There are no short cuts, it takes years and you need to listen to your body. Don't power through pain or it will catch up with you later.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Cross-fit and its boxes is doing a lot of damage to the reputation of traditional bar bell training by emphasizing weight and reps over form and technique. I dunno, traditional bar bell weightlifting's reputation as some hard thing for which most people casually interested in fitness want a shortcut, which its had AFAICT pretty much as long as I've been alive, seems pretty solidly intact and unthreatened by Cross-Fit. If Cross-Fit is certifying unready coaches producing a wave of injuries that eventually are going to get notice, the reputation damaged will be Cross-Fit's.
- jacques_chester 11y ago> the reputation of traditional bar bell training There was no reputation. Almost nobody knew what weightlifting was.
- oldmanjay 11y agoIs this a serious common modern belief? Weightlifting was exceedingly popular in my youth, which by millenial scale was ancient history but in actual real terms was in living memory.
- jacques_chester 11y agoWhen I started in 2007 there were perhaps three dozen registered weightlifters in Western Australia (where I lived at the time). There are now hundreds. As a sport it's undergoing a second renaissance in the anglosphere. There's no other obvious cause apart from millions of crossfitters taking it up.
- dalke 11y agoThe account name "oldmanjay" suggests to me that the "exceedingly popular in my youth" refers to the first "renaissance in the anglosphere". That is, http://www.awf.com.au/history/HallOfFame.aspx http://www.awf.com.au/history/HallOfFame.aspx says that the 1970s were "“the golden years” of the sport" in Australia, and there are many here who were youths in the 1970s. So when you write "Almost nobody knew what weightlifting was", what population were you considering? If it's predominately those in their 20s ("millenial scale") then you should consider oldmanjay's comment as suggesting there's a bias error in your 'almost nobody.' While it's not all that indicative, Google ngrams gives an interesting comparison between the use of 'weighlifting' in "British English" at https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=weightlifting&year_start=1920&year_end=2000&corpus=18&smoothing=3&share=&direct_url=t1%3B%2Cweightlifting%3B%2Cc0 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=weightlifting&... vs "American English" at https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=weightlifting&year_start=1920&year_end=2000&corpus=17&smoothing=3&share=&direct_url=t1%3B%2Cweightlifting%3B%2Cc0 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=weightlifting&... . There's a clear drop in British English during the 1980s, which is what I would expect from your first/second renaissance description, but it doesn't exist in the US English chart. So another possibility is that oldmanjay comes from the US. Also, in attempting to verify your statement concerning the "perhaps three dozen registered weightlifters in WA" I found the 2007 AWF report at http://www.awf.com.au/governance/docs/Annual%20Report%202007%20with%20Finance%20Report.pdf http://www.awf.com.au/governance/docs/Annual%20Report%202007... . Under "Number of Lifters in the Top 10 Male Rankings by State" are 58 from Western Australia, and under "Number of Lifters in the Top 10 Female Rankings by State" are 39 from Western Australia. This sounds like there were easily more than three dozen registered weightlifters in WA. I didn't carefully check to see if there were duplicate names, but a spot examination shows few overlaps. And in any case, these are only the top 10 winners. How do you know there were "perhaps three dozen registered weightlifters in Western Australia" when the limited evidence I can find suggests there were more than that?
- jacques_chester 11y ago> there are many here who were youths in the 1970s. The 70s are definitely before my time. Going on what I read from those who were adults in the 70s, it seems like the golden era for the anglosphere was the 50s and 60s. By the 1970s the Russians dominated the sport. > This sounds like there were easily more than three dozen registered weightlifters in WA. There's a capitation table. 77 registered lifters (~six dozen, I was off by 2x) in the whole of WA in 2007. In 2008 it fell to 68. I can't find more recent numbers, they seem to have stopped publishing the capitation table. For what it's worth, I competed for five years, during which Crossfit exploded in popularity. They have been a massive shot in the arm for strength sports. It used to be that I'd say I was a weightlifter and people would ask me for tips on bicep curls. Now I have a chance that someone will ask me about my competition total.
- Kopion 11y agoIt is tough to take your post with any authority when you don't spell it correctly - CrossFit.