3 ms·
Outside as a legitimate source of anything is a joke. That publication is the National Enquirer of the outdoor sports world. As far as the 'CrossFit causes more
by briandear 11y ago
Outside as a legitimate source of anything is a joke. That publication is the National Enquirer of the outdoor sports world. As far as the 'CrossFit causes more injuries' meme (which incidentally has been promoted by people with a vested interest in CrossFit competitors,) is there any data to support the allegations? Outside is the same publication that declared Manaslu too dangerous for commercial expeditions and promotes a wide range of falsehoods and distortions about Everest. If their track record on mountaineering coverage is any indicator, their CrossFit articles are likely equally biased and inaccurate.
- ectoplasm 11y agoUncle Rhabdo?
- justinator 11y agoAs the article mentions, when you try to do as many reps of say an Olympic lift in a certain amount of time - like the squat, it's very easy to undermine proper form, which is what leads to injuries in CrossFit. Since Crossfit is gaining popularity, a lot of these types of lifts are introduced and learned within a Crossfit gym, so there's little time to be acquainted with the proper way to do the lift. Thus, when someone leaves/quits the gym, they're not leaving with much of value: the strength they gain isn't specific to any one sport (unless that sport is, "CrossFit" which is also a headscratcher), and the exercises they've learned could have been done for years improperly. That's another recipe for injury. That's a lot of strange minuses for a gym that's very expensive to belong to. My comment was a joke, but the problem with injuries due to improper form while lifting is very real. It's not specific to CrossFit, but as I've mentioned, the focus on # reps in a specific amount of time can exasperates that problem. I myself have no investment in any commercial competitors of CrossFit. I'm a very fit person, but not in any way to CrossFit would measure. What I see personally in a CrossFit physique is a lot of muscle and weight that doesn't do a lot of good in the areas of sport that I practice: running, cycling, and climbing - all of which benefit from a strength to weight ratio that would not be attainable utilizing a CrossFit regime. CrossFit ideas have been attempted to be shoehorned into these things (CrossFit Endurance), but it's seemed as somewhat of a joke, if you're anything close to an elite athlete.
- justinator 11y agoWill the New York Times be a better source for information? http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/22/fashion/thursdaystyles/getting-fit-even-if-it-kills-you.html http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/22/fashion/thursdaystyles/get... It is a legitimate question - I'm actually pretty wary of most main stream media outlets - not unlike yourself.