Having loosely followed the QPC that has just been rejected, I think it's pretty clear they had a case. We should also see the details of this decision. They

Having loosely followed the QPC that has just been rejected, I think it's pretty clear they had a case. We should also see the details of this decision. They may have interpreted the law (and documented that interpretation) in a way that makes it less unacceptable. Also, there will a couple other recourse for that same law. It's not over yet.