4 ms·
Why isn't it easier for employees to sell shares of private companies?
by chrisco255 11y ago
Why isn't it easier for employees to sell shares of private companies?
- j_baker 11y agoBecause there's no one they can sell their shares to. With a public company, you can sell your shares on the stock market.
- zkhalique 11y agoPerhaps they should be able to sell their shares back to the company? The company would be responsible for raising more money and have some allocation for share buyback.
- exelius 11y agoWho would determine the price of common shares without a liquid market?
- tptacek 11y agoOther employees, the management team, and the board.
- apalmer 11y agowhich is exactly the problem.
- exelius 11y agoYep, all of those people stand to gain from setting as low a price as possible given that a liquidity event will reset the share price anyway. Not to mention that any buybacks would hit your run rate, because run rates are about operating cash flows and not valuation numbers (and buybacks are just a way to convert operating cash into equity).
- wglb 11y agoAnd often with consultation with outside valuation consultants.
- zkhalique 11y agoWho determines them when you raise money from investors? That's the market that should determine the value of the shares obviously. The last price fetched on that market. Whether its liquidity is high or low, it's still a viable market, even if it's not the public stock market.
- jstelly 11y agoThe same people/method the company is using to determine the strike price of any new options they are issuing?
- tptacek 11y agoA few very good companies do make this possible, but it takes effort to set up and is not the default.
- scurvy 11y agoSome well-run startups make arrangements for this when raising a round. The VC will agree to buy into the round at X dollars per share. They'll also agree to buy up to Y dollars worth of stock from employees who want to sell. VC gets more ownership of the company, and the company doesn't have to give up more ownership. It's overall a good situation. I know that Cloudflare and a few other companies offer this.
- hatred 11y agoMost companies have a Right of first refusal clause embedded in the options agreement effectively limiting selling shares of private companies even after exercising options. If they are RSU's , I am assuming they can't be sold at all in the private markets ? Can anyone with prior experience elablorate on these ?
- beambot 11y agoIt's due to the SEC. The SEC places restrictions on who can buy shares in the private startups -- eg. you need to be an "accredited investor" to purchase them (>$1M liquid assets or >$200k/yr earnings). The SEC also places limits on the number of shareholders a company can have without (effectively) going public... which creates an incentive for startups to disallow current/former employees from selling their shares on the semi-private market.
- hatred 11y agoThat explains it. Thanks !
- joshjkim 11y agoIt's getting easier with companies like sharespost.com but securities regulation generally discourage the sale of private company stock in any "open" (aka. public) way - this is ostensibly to protect buyers of stock from investing in risky assets that they know little about and for which there is little public information. Buyers are generally hesitant because they want to get financial info and other private data to make an analytic investment decision. Given that VC-style investment are more normalized now and they aren't as based on fundamentals, investors are definitely more willing to invest without private financials BUT really large asset managers (who spend 99% of their funds on public stocks with their expansive disclosures) will not tolerate this, limiting the market. Besides, they are getting common stock, which sucks compared to the other investors who get preferred stock. Companies don't usually want this to happen because they don't want a shareholder (who has voting and other legal rights) that they don't know or trust, and who is not aligned with them in the way that employees and VC are (supposed to be..ha). The solution growing in popularity tries to deal with all of these by having a company organize a secondary offering, like what pinterest does (palantir does it too, twilio recently did, so do a bunch of companies). Usually this means the company knows the buyer (sometimes an existing investor) and basically gives them the info they would give a VC, except the investors buys employee shares rather than new stock - sometimes this will be asked for an investor when they are doing a preferred stock deal, and the investor will agree as an additional "company favorable" term. Important to note here too, that USUALLY the biggest sellers in these deals are the founders, so while it's a very nice thing for them to do for their employees, there's some healthy self-interest there as well =)
- scurvy 11y agoIt's damn near impossible to find a buyer without financials. Unless you work at a unicorn that raises money on hype, you're going to have a really tough time.
- s73v3r 11y agoBecause that would make you less tied to the company.