3 ms·
This is complicated because of how ad networks work and all the layers involved. We have somewhat of a standard called RTB (real-time bidding) where an exchang
by manigandham 11y ago
This is complicated because of how ad networks work and all the layers involved.
We have somewhat of a standard called RTB (real-time bidding) where an exchange will see each impression and run an auction in 100ms for each ad slot and then take the winning bid and render it on the page. That was easy and efficient when it was just an image. Now ad formats have become more "engaging" and require javascript tags to run (like those expanding ads). So now the exchange tag wont just load an image but load more JS tags to render the ad.
Then we have DMPs (data management platforms) that are solely about measuring your audience. Each one is a isolated silo of data and they dont share because they all have their own algorithms and backend connections with offline data sources to provide value. Most publishers and networks however have to work with all of them since ad buyers want access to everything or they wont spend.
Then we have the new 3rd layer of vendors who do ad fraud and viewability (measuring whether an ad is actually visible in the browser window) which is yet more tags to make sure the original ads are actually rendered and worth something. Then there are some ad networks that don't work through RTB exchanges that need their own tags on the page.
An additional tag isn't the problem, it's the fact that these networks are designed to just offload as much as possible to yet more providers which means a single 5kb tag can balloon into dozens of requests which all load their own crappy frameworks to do the same thing. 10 small tags on a page are fine. 10 small tags that load 25 tags each is what's killing these sites.
Disclaimer: I've built ad networks and run my own now.
EDIT: I wanted to add that part of what I'm pushing for in the industry is more regulation not only with business practices and data but also technical certification. Something to prove that an ad network is actually designed well and won't be a burden on sites/users. Then buyers can just trust that certification without asking for all these 3rd party vendor verification tags that slow down sites and increase cost. Any ideas for making this happen would be appreciated.
- look_lookatme 11y ago> So now the exchange tag wont just load an image but load more JS tags to render the ad. Not to mention that more and more this javascript is spent calculating whether an ad is being viewed are not and phoning that data back home. Ad providers do this in different ways and it's not uncommon to see them send down a full jQuery build with their ad.
- manigandham 11y agoYes, I mentioned all this in the other paragraphs. Ad networks have a lot of work put into the backend systems but the frontend stuff that runs in the browser has been ignored for a long time. Even Google still uses things like Document.Write for putting more tags on the page, something that was obsolete about 6 years ago.
- lmorchard 11y agoThanks for all these details! My rant was largely based on guessing what's going on with all the stuff.
- manigandham 11y agoOf course. The more consumers know the better we can solve all this. Honestly, I don't agree with the blocking all 3rd party cookies and adblock. It's a blunt-force approach that is harming more than helping right now, but I do agree with the reasons why it's happening and I'm hoping that it will finally change the situation.
- Terr_ 11y agoYou might attack it from a non-technical perspective, where the "Decent Ads" certification says something about how their business practices are set up with SLAs or policies for who is at fault if an advertisement contains malware. Alternately, a technical benchmarking-only system, where you try to identify how much their contribution is to page-load without respect to security/etc.
- manigandham 11y agoYes the IAB (Internet Advertising Bureau) and MRC (media ratings council) and 4A's (American Association of Advertising Agencies) all have various "standards" and certifications. There are similar groups in Europe and smaller orgs that focus on niche areas. Unfortunately for the most part these groups all charge lots of money for a nice seal you can put on your site, without any real checking of a business. Some of the most offending and insecure networks are members of the IAB. [1] Not to mention this has no bearing on actual technical implementations. The MRC does audits of companies to certify them for measuring viewability but there can be 50% or more discrepancy[2] between vendors which ultimately makes the entire thing pointless. And buyers also don't care, they have their own "favorite" vendors they want to work with so they're not even interchangeable. The adblock plus company in Germany (while I dont agree with their entire stance) has an "acceptable ads" standard that at least lays out something in terms of user experience. However they accept money for whitelisting which is why all those crummy clickbait widgets like outbrain/taboola still show up through the default ABP filters. What I want to see is actual legal regulation that covers how a business deals with data/privacy and then some kind of technical certification led by a real tech-savvy company to vet ad networks and their implementations. However this industry is full of political motives and other shady dealings so it takes a herculean effort to do anything... Maybe with some consumer backing there might be changes given the wide usage of adblock today but (not) surprisingly most digital ad execs see it as some kind of plague rather than the direct consequences of industry actions. That's not a very cooperative attitude for enacting change. [1] http://www.iab.net/member_center/1521/1534 http://www.iab.net/member_center/1521/1534 [2] http://adexchanger.com/data-driven-thinking/viewability-lets-end-the-numbers-game/ http://adexchanger.com/data-driven-thinking/viewability-lets...