12 ms·
State-managed capitalism and socialism are not the same thing. Putting a state-run monopoly in private hands (which is what's usually done), instead in state-r
by kristopolous 11y ago
State-managed capitalism and socialism are not the same thing. Putting a state-run monopoly in private hands (which is what's usually done), instead in state-run hands ... where the risks and profits are held by the same entity instead of the public bearing the risk and the private sector getting the profits? That's socialism? No...
This guy's a professor of political economy ... what a terrible word choice he's using.
According to him, not blindly gifting away the collectively-held public commons into the hands of private capital to sell it back to us is now called "Socialism".
What's next? Insisting cities which build private sports stadiums with public funds participate in profit sharing instead of just presenting the stadium with a little bow on top to some billionaire? Woah, Socialism cometh!
The real thing that's happening is that people want a fair shake... "If we're going to be on the hook in the bad times, then we should see some of the good time too." The companies that were bailed out with public funds now have record private profits ... that's the problem. It's got zilch to do with socialism.
- calibraxis 11y agoHe's writing for the NYT. I haven't read Gar Alperovitz's works closely, but he seems quite a serious thinker. I'm currently giving him the benefit of the doubt, that he has to phrase his message in certain ways to get published in NYT.
- trentmb 11y agoThey seem to 'know' their audience- the NYT isn't an academic economics journal, so playing a bit loose with terminology is OK- the simple fact is amongst the people at large socialism=government controlled as opposed to worker owned.... or some other academic definition I'm ignorant of.
- kristopolous 11y agoI understand ... I just don't want the idea of being fiscally prudent and economically responsible with municipal resources at a structural level to be stigmatized as a form of socialism. It's just an act of diligence and paying attention.
- twblalock 11y agoWere you under the impression that the author intends to stigmatize anything, or believes that socialism is a bad thing? He is clearly in favor of public ownership.
- kristopolous 11y agoSure he is. But if I wanted more of something, calling it "socialist" is probably not a winning strategy to help convergence numbers.
- richmarr 11y agoIt feels like 'socialism' (which is actually closer to an optimum model than free markets for some types of problem) needs to undergo the same identity shift in the US that started for black & gay people after the Second World War. It's the stigma that's a problem, not the 'socialism'
- kristopolous 11y agoThe biggest thing that needs to happen is the realization socialism can exist next to capitalism just like charities, private clubs and other types of charters. Replacing any class of duality based thinking with multiplicity based ones seems to be really hard for people. The capitalism/socialism false binary is pretty ingrained
- richmarr 11y agoSounds reasonable. Perhaps the 'ism' is the problem; it sounds like an encompassing ideology rather than a tool.
- twblalock 11y agoActually, socialism is a broad enough term to encompass state ownership as well as worker ownership or control. That's true in academia as well as in non-academic discourse. State ownership of major industries, without worker control, often accomplished through nationalization of pre-existing industries, has been a characteristic policy of socialist political parties and governments throughout the 20th century. For example, almost every major industry in the UK was nationalized in the 1940s, and such action was labeled as socialism by both its proponents and opponents. Under this most prevalent usage of the term, state ownership of an electrical utility or a sovereign wealth fund certainly qualifies.
- trentmb 11y agoI feel like a doofus asking this- I was always under the (false?) impression that socialists and fascists were diametric opposites- how is a nation asserting rule over an industry socialist, but not fascist?
- verinus 11y agowell i think that is only due to latest history, but take Nazi party of WWII for example: nazi is short for national sozialist; NSDAP for nationalsozialistische deutsche arbeiter partei (national socialist german labor party)
- calibraxis 11y agoPerfectly sensible question! Meanings of words drift. And these are historic real-world movements; the definitions don't come from dictionaries. Orwellian propaganda muddies the waters: the Nazis called themselves "socialists"; East Germany under the Soviet Union called itself the "German Democratic Republic". These quotes seem to be helpful: "I mean fascism pretty much in the traditional sense, [analogous to] a system in which the state integrates labor and capital under their control. The ideal is top-down control with the public essentially following orders." (http://www.ontheissues.org/Celeb/Noam_Chomsky_Corporations.htm http://www.ontheissues.org/Celeb/Noam_Chomsky_Corporations.h...) "Now, as far as socialism is concerned, that term has been so evacuated of content over the last century, that it’s hard even to use. I mean, the Soviet Union was called a socialist society by the two major propaganda operations in the world: the western one and the Soviet one. They both called it socialism for opposite reasons." (https://tansafte.wordpress.com/2013/03/07/some-footnotes-for-the-video-chomsky-on-socialism/ https://tansafte.wordpress.com/2013/03/07/some-footnotes-for...)
- twblalock 11y agoMost of the examples in the article are about state-owned, state-operated enterprises, such as sovereign wealth funds, utilities, oil and mineral extraction, etc. In fact, I could not find any example of "putting a state-run monopoly in private hands" anywhere in the article. Did you even read it? > According to him, not blindly gifting away the collectively-held public commons into the hands of private capital to sell it back to us is now called "Socialism". That's quite a strawman there. He never argued anything remotely like that.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoI think those to examples are intended to describe "privatization" as it's often done (i.e. badly from an purely economic perspective, because it's partly/mostly ideological) which is, as you note, the exact opposite of the article's focus, which is state run stuff that makes economic sense. That's combined with pedantry about the term "socialism", which has confused some readers of the comment. So kristopolous appears to approve of certain things being run by the state, and would prefer that not to be described as socialism, as it might put people off who immediately dismiss anything with that label, and lead to more economically silly privatization or public subsidy of private profit.
- baddox 11y agoI don't see a very significant distinction between "a state-run monopoly in private hands" and "a state-run monopoly in state-run hands." Each person is still an individual, after all, with "private" incentives. Whether their title is technically a government job is irrelevant, as long as their money is coming from government either directly (from the government budget) or indirectly (thanks to a government-enforced monopoly).
- kristopolous 11y agoThe differences are in the kinds of risks taken, how the revenue is allocated, and how the profits are handled. The incentive structure of the two systems are different. This changes the outcome.
- baddox 11y agoCan you explain how the incentive structures differ? They don't seem significantly different to me.
- kristopolous 11y agoCapital driven entities excel by maximizing revenue and minimizing cost. They perpetuate themselves and insulate their volatility by building vast warchests. A public equivalence however, excels by maximizing utility. They perpetuate themselves by making sure the value they provide is near the cost they incur. Take a gym for example. A private one wants to maximize membership dues but minimize actual facility use - that maximizes profit. A public one wants to be something that the community utilizes. Generally speaking, in a public equivalence, the only party to enrich in the exchange is the customer base. Now given this, a homogeneous state-run society sounds foolish ... but America's homogeneous capitalist society is equally foolhardy. We are sophisticated enough to analyze things and apply appropriate incentivized structures upon them instead of using the same one inappropriately in every use-case.
- baddox 11y ago